April 2020 by Joe N.
I have gone here for many years but last night we had the large Chicago 7 pizza. $28 !! And hardly any toppings as you can see. I hate to be mean during this tough time. Ladies working hard at the place all nice people etc. pizza not good sorry to say.
April 2020 by Kylie Agatha
I ordered curb side pick up. They saw me and never brought the food out. I had to go up with customers not wearing masks. Totally not made my day. Finally got my order. Don't bother getting food from here. No extra cheese that I had ordered...and the pizza was burnt totally disgusting. I will never get food from here. The quality went to the shiter
March 2020 by Eric Murinko
The food and beer is awesome. Always a stop for me and my child on my time off. If any of your employees see this tell them thanks and we will see them in a few months.
March 2020 by Austin Wang
The food is good and there are lots of options to make sure that whatever your tastes are, there is probably a dish that you would enjoy. The service can be slow but in my opinion not outrageously slow; waiting never really bothered me that much, and considering their large portions personally I don't really care that much about how long it takes.
March 2020 by Steve Douglas
The food was really good as usual. Wait staff seems to be hit or miss however. On our last visit I don't know if they were understaffed, but it took forever for the check to come.
February 2020 by Patrick Busteed
Old C's is a great neighborhood establishment. I go primarily because of the service which is excellent, the buzztime competitions, and good food. The buzztime competitors are by far the best in fort Collins. Best I've ever seen. My brother and wife love the Italian nachos!
February 2020 by Fred Archuleta
Food was great. Prices are good. Clean and well maintained. Teamwork could be improved with the staff.
February 2020 by Julio Cobb
Loved the service and the food. Nice atmosphere. Wasn't too loud but wasn't quiet. I enjoyed my time.
February 2020 by Brittani L.
Not a great night at the Old C. Food was great. Even tried the ale crust that was pretty good. Hint dip the crust in the cheese for the pretzel bites! Back to the off night though. It was not busy and our waitress was not grand. I try to give the waitress the benefit but when you are not slammed and I have to go to the bar to refill the tables drinks that is annoying appetizers took a hot minute to come to the table. And the last complaint I have is Petty but they did not even serve the first slice! That is what they are known for. Oh well chalk it up to an off night
January 2020 by Robert Kaczanowski
Great pizza. Always busy on Fri and Sat evenings. great place to dine w/ friends. Huge selection of beers.
January 2020 by Andrea Burger
Horrible food and even worse drinks tonight. Don't order anything but beer here. I can't believe it because Old C's used to be one of our favorites. The salad off the salad menu was the size of a side salad in a different bowl. The fish looked very different from how they show it on the menu which was odd. Very disappointed. Disgusted, especially after the worst martini I've ever had. I'm sorry I had to post a complaint. But I hope this helps them get it right IF there is a next time for us.
January 2020 by Kerry S.
Delivered food was cold, missing an appetizer. The Italian nachos were on was paper which stuck to the melted cheese affecting 25% of the total dish. Chicken pesto had 2 pieces of chicken but 10 pieces of broccoli. Overall this place is good onsite but delivery was sub-par.
January 2020 by Sandra W.
I have discovered the Old Chicago Pizza and Taproom. Everything I've ordered has been great. The pizza I ordered was the best I've had in years.i will certainly keep coming back as I haven't found anything I didn't like.
January 2020 by Jessica Delgado
Anna G. Was an amazing server! The food was great and the atmosphere was energetic! Thank you
January 2020 by Suzanne Dannahower
Very good pizza. We all had a personal pizza. More than what one person can consume. Great value for the money. I love the thin crust, the kids went for the thicker one.
January 2020 by Brian Bliss
Old C's had their day of relevance in Fort Collins, but now it's a tired relic of the past. Pizzas still consistently good, they just lost their mojo. Far better places to have a better experience can be found.
January 2020 by Loretta May
We came early on New Year's Eve (around 5:30). After waiting 15 minutes to put our name on the list, we were told they had only 3 servers for the entire restaurant, and it would be at least 50 minutes before we were seated! Terrible! We left after 40 minutes and were told it would still be another 30 minutes! Ridiculous! We WON'T be returning! ☹
December 2019 by greg kurtz
Excited to see cauliflower buffalo bites on the menu. Ordered and the excitement vanished when served. Disgusting to say the least. Half a plate of wilted florets with some oily sauce squirted on top with burn bits all over. Poor job at best and can’t believe the kitchen decided, yes serve these because.... Never again and I recommend nobody else order this plate of cr......
December 2019 by Adam Crawford
Don’t get their chicken and avocado sandwich unless you want just spinach and lettuce. Had 1 slice of avocado in my entire salad and barely any chicken. They also forgot my garlic bread. Not worth the $12 price tag.
December 2019 by Rae
We've been sitting for 40 minutes. It's my moms birthday. 20 minutes to even get waters.
November 2019 by Barry G.
Very poor service during this particular visit. Not anywhere near the expectations we have for Old Chicago.
November 2019 by Melissa Lacey
We were on our way to a bad experience. Waiting quite awhile to get service. Then Sidney saved the day! Told her we were going to see a movie and she moved our dinner along quickly while giving us excellent service! Thank you Sydney!
November 2019 by Jenni Herin
Absolutely wonderful service, food, and energetic atmosphere. I would highly reccomend the waiter Max. Max was fun, warm, and inviting. He was very knowledgable over the menus (both beer and food) Max made sure to tell us all the good deals and best food selections. But most importantly, it was a very busy night and Max made sure to keep us updated on our food, our drinks full all while keeping us laughing and joking. Thanks Old Chicago and Max for a great dinnertonight! !
October 2019 by Kent Trompeter
Great service, food and beer.
October 2019 by paulwG4538EK
Ordered pizza online to take to a small party with grand parents. We didn’t discover the results until we got to their residence. Trip took about 15 minutes. Out of three pizzas, one was completely wrong. All three were cold and hard. They apparently had been ready for some time before we got them. Crusts were very thin and crunchy. Not good!
October 2019 by Doug Nagle
18 people at the bar. One bar tender. Always. Worst service error. Ordered food, one hour later no food. The service is the worst in Fort Collins. And food mediocre at best. Do not recommend old c’s. This is the fourth time I’ve had this experience there. Management should be fired.
October 2019 by KaLynn Painter
Used to be a regular patron of old c's but quit going for awhile, figured I'd give it another try after a bad experience a few months back. And it got worse, so much worse. Service was slow. Waited over 20 minutes for a glass of wine even though the restaurant was only 10% full. Food took over 45 minutes to receive (ordered things like french fries and personal pizzas) and only got about half of what we ordered originally. Everything was cold even after a super long wait. Manager was super helpful at the end of the meal I would like to note. But, unfortunately we won't be returning.
October 2019 by Ashwin D.
Big fan of their happy hour menus. Also, love their flights - customizable and they have a ton of beer. Its a great place. The Thai Pie is a personal favorite. Sports bar ambiance and can get quite loud.
September 2019 by Sara Butler
Food is good for the most part and at a decent price. Wait time unfortunately is long. Have tried this location multiple times, even ordering for pick up and through grubhub. First time we waited almost an hour to receive our food, grubhub delivery ended up being delayed and when ordering for pick up I sat for 20 minutes when my food was sitting on the counter due to their "process" consisting of who got there first regardless of whose food was ready.
September 2019 by Lauren M.
This was probably some of the worst service we've received in Fort Collins. They took ten minutes to seat us when the restaurant was empty, then it took another ten minutes for someone to come by and take our drink order. I arrived at 6:50pm with my son after his sports practice on a Thursday night and they made no effort to be attentive or timely. When the food finally arrived, an hour after we ordered it, it was cold. Giving two stars because I've worked in restaurants before and I know that often the service is not entirely in the control of the waitstaff if the kitchen is running behind.