March 2020 by meadow sinner
All honesty wasn’t a fan the pizzas and pastas just feel short and tasted a little weird the appetizers were good though. Also service was cruddy.
March 2020 by Stephanie H.
We ordered three appetizers, one didn't come. After realizing it wasn't going to come, I flagged down our server and told her to forget it and please make sure we wouldn't be charged for it. Our pizza took a long time and was not right once it finally was served. We ate it as is because it took so long. We had three people in our party that had birthdays. We asked our server for happy bday to be sung at our table for them. Never happened. We do not live in the area but, if we did, we wouldn't be back.
March 2020 by Jeff J.
Holy schnikees! I cant believe I have yet to review this old Chicago location seeing as this is one of my favorite bars/restaurants in the area. I cant decide which one I like better if its the Ft. Collins one or the Loveland one, I mean for fucks sake they're both wonderful. Issac & Brittany are both phenomenal fucking bar tenders & they always succeed in getting me shit faced drunk. They do that because even before my beer is empty they're already bringing me another cold one to throw down my stupid ass throat. You gotta try the double deckeroni pizza its so fucking badass & I believe the secret is they add tabasco sauce to it which adds the perfect amount of spice to it. Great spot for this one too, just a hop skip & a jump from i-25 plus several other bars right in the same god damn strip in case you're gonna do some serious drinking. I for one cant fucking wait to come back here & I hope you'll find time in your busy schedule to join me, if you do then the first round is on me bro dawgs!
February 2020 by Shawn Brown
Great pizza and wings. They have a unique menu with something to delight any tastebuds. Great selection of beer, but I still had Bud Light. I would recommend that you try their Italian Nachos. Those are simply amazing. The flavor combo is so wonderful, you will wonder how come you never thought of that. We went in the evening time around Seven. There was no wait for our small group of three. I highly recommend this place!
February 2020 by Mike Prestel
Great beer and food. Their pizza is the best. I always get good service here. One big problem is that the fans are on above the bar and it’s very uncomfortable to the point I either I have to wear a coat or leave the restaurant. It’s February and it’s 25 degrees let’s try the heater. It’s happened more than once here.
January 2020 by Roy Steele
Just had the buffet today. My wife and I could not be more unhappy. A few other patrons felt the same way. Buffet ends at 1:30pm. We ordered at 1pm and there was very little pizza left at that time. At 1:15pm they added (2) veggie pizzas. At that time only a few old pieces of pizza were left at the buffet. Some other people asked if there would be any other pizza brought out and the kitchen server said "no". They didn't add more pizza. We told the manager that several people were unhappy and he just apologized. Extremely poor customer service.
January 2020 by Kevin Wonder
Food is good for the price, service is usually on point but occasionally it's a bit slow. My only major complaint, is the bar is often chilly. Not sure if it's the fans or the temperature, but they need to fix that.
January 2020 by Mitchell O'Rourke
Good lunch pizza buffet. Came with soup or salad. Good pizza.
January 2020 by Vanessa Johnson
We love old Chicago's for their late night eats and brews, but we return for reliably good service. This old Chicago's is new to us, but was predictably awesome.
January 2020 by Lonnie Turner
It was amazing! The wings are on point! The chocolate cake was great not to sweet! Perfect, Beer was good and cold! Waitress was nice and friendly I will come back for sure
January 2020 by C Ubstans
We had an awesome experience and the food was "Oh So Delicioso!"
January 2020 by Bob Caster
Love the large selection of beer and the food is always good
December 2019 by Leah Romarine
Italian nachos are awesome!! Our waitress was great too!
December 2019 by Heather Gwin
Way over priced for the quality. It was bottom line food for a big steak dinner price. Not impressed at all
December 2019 by Jo B.
OMG, that wss fracking HORRIBLE. Chicken fried chicken was over cooked, potatos were nasty. Service sub par. Not IMPRESSED AT ALL for Loveland.
December 2019 by Ross V.
Need cheese & red sauce? Old Chicago has you covered: pizza, calzones, pepperoni rolls, spaghetti, lasagne -- and it's all dependably good. Or if you need a change of pace the burgers, sandwiches and even fish & chips (crispy!) are tasty. Best of all the beer list is exceptional, offering a "best of" selection of seasonal, specialty and perennial microbrews. Lately the service has been especially attentive and friendly.
November 2019 by Holden Wierema
This was ridiculous. We were promptly seated by a hostess and the waitress brought our drinks. We were then forced to wait about 25 minutes to even order our food. I could understand this if the restaurant was very busy, but there were only about five other groups in the whole place. The food was prepared relatively quickly, however my grandfather’s lasagna was mostly frozen and my burger was burned as can be. The service is not usually this bad at this restaurant, but I honestly think that the waitress should be thoroughly apprehended.
November 2019 by Emma Blandford
The environment was very friendly and upbeat! the staff was very helpful and easy to get along with. i will definitely be back!
November 2019 by Dawnette Diltz
Food was good except they forgot salads but the service and drinks were really below par for here. They normally have great service too. Was disappointed it's one of our favorite places.
October 2019 by Andrea Josefina Cruz
Good music, warm atmosphere, great bartender... Delicious pub pizza
October 2019 by Bob T.
Walked in to pick up a pizza someone else ordered. One med size. They call it large $29. Smashed against the side of the box in an ocean heap. Got stung never again. Cancelled my points card too. I expected maybe $20 tops but they are pricing themselves over the top. Quality was mediocre
October 2019 by derek probizanski
First time, and what can I say other than the fact the service is amazing, fast and polite and the food is mind blowing good. The atmosphere is great. Wish I could give it 10 stars. Will sure be coming back. If you try this place you will not be disappointed!
September 2019 by Jamie Wallace
Very disappointed with the pricey pizza I bought from the Loveland Old Chicago. The â€œroastedâ€ garlic was actually raw, not very well chopped garlic, put on so heavy that none of us could eat it. $25 dollars down the drain. I wish I could include the photo I took of all the raw garlic I tired to pick off of just the first half of one piece of pizza. Will not being buying pizza from them again. I will say though that the fried pickles and mac & cheese starters are very good, but I’d stay away from the pizza.
September 2019 by Paul F.
My spouse and I come her every Tuesday night for date night. We love reduced price appetizers before 6pm and $5 tall boys!! Tonight just showed once again why this is our favorite restaurant. We ordered the Spicy Beer Chicken pizza and at first we noticed it was doughy and underdone. My wife hesitated to say something, but I said "Hey you don't deserve to eat pizza dough!" When we went to mention it the server he said it was prepared wrong. We were relieved. When they cooked it again and served it we loved it! They also said we will get $5 off next week and a free beer for the trouble. Once again, our favorite restaurant!!
September 2019 by Jason Powers
We showed up service was great got set quickly, And went downhill from there food was good but it took for ever to come out. The ranch was so bland we didn't know if it was just milk . Must make that in house because it was horrible.. And to top it off turn the lights Way down before 7 o'clock. They have a bar and a family restaurant But it seems they just want to be a bar.
September 2019 by Mariano M.
Never will eat at old Chicago anywhere. After long day of hiking Estes park Colorado. We decided to drive into Loveland Co and try old Chicago pizza. The waitress was polite and took our order. Brought pizza and salad to table in less than ten minutes. Brought wrong salad dressing and wrong pizza. She said wrote order wrong. She said basically the same pizza. It was not hot and tasted like cardboard. I New something was wrong. When people next to us ordered before us and when we were leaving were brought Hot pizza. Felt ripped off.
September 2019 by Cameron Custer
Had a wonderful experience. The manager allowed me to make a reservation and place flowers at the table for a special occasion. They even waited on me while I changed a flat tire. Tim the manager that evening was exceptional. Along with our waitress. Thank you for the wonderful experience.
September 2019 by Spencer Lackey
Ordered online and was quoted as being ready by 7:12. Finally received the order around 7:25. Also paid extra money for a side salad I did not receive. They did make sure to provide me with the dressing for the salad though. Overall not the best first impression for someone new in town.
September 2019 by Amanda C.
In the evenings, this Old Chicago location is stellar for a good burger or pizza. If you're looking for somewhere to go for lunch though, maybe reconsider if this place comes to mind. After a roughly 35 minute wait in a nearly empty dining room, my meal (pretty obviously microwaved) was shoved in front of me by a wait-staff that acted like they'd rather be on jury duty. Usually I love this place for dinner. Lunch though, not so much.
August 2019 by Steve Wilson
Wonderful family atmosphere. Great food. Good variety