August 2018 by Jim Taber
Great place to unwind and enjoy good food, drink and listen to some music! The staff is top notch!!
August 2018 by Joe Desiderio
A local favorite with good food, great service and fantastic owners.
August 2018 by Phyllis Bellamy
Great atmosphere Kelly and staff very friendly well recommended
July 2018 by Charles F.
Best food in town! We got the Ruben and the Marty and both sandwiches were amazing! Not to mention the place is very cute and quaint!
May 2018 by Bryan Vanderweide
Classic Irish Pub. Good food and great drink sections. Live music and good service. Great stop not too far from the visitor center.
May 2018 by justin wright
I really loved this place! It is an Irish Pub with a lot of charm and character. The bartender Morgan was incredibly sweet and gave great service. I should mention that when I first sat down there wasn't anyone else in the place. I stopped in for a beer and a sandwich. They had about seven beers on tap and plenty more in bottles/cans. I chose to 'build my own' sandwich. It came out fast and was delicious. This is one of the few places I've been to in St. Augustine that feels like a local hangout.
May 2018 by Amanda C.
Wanted to love this place, but they microwave the Ruben and pastrami sandwiches vs using a grill. That's a no for me. The microwave turned my pastrami into rubber.
May 2018 by Stephen Howell
Great quaint place to relax inside or on the front porch. Plus, they have a nice selection of bottled, can and draught beer; a wide variety of mixed drinks and a good choice of sandwiches. The open-mic night included some great talent, and the bar staff were friendly. Highly recommended!
March 2018 by R H.
Went to Ann O'Mallys on an early Sunday evening. I had read that this was a small place but had no idea how really tiny it is. About six tables inside 10 seats at the bar and a few tables on the front porch. They offer beer and wine only at the bar. I think the place was not necessarily clean but the sandwiches were delicious so I will overlook that point. We had chicken salad on rye and the Marty (pastrami). Served w chips and a pickle, very reasonably priced.
March 2018 by Brian G.
To be fair I didn't end up eating in there. We came in and were basically ignored for a while.
Looked the menu up on line and it was nothing special and walked out.
I really don't understand how this place has such high ratings.
March 2018 by Gina Rodriguez
Looks small, but an excellent place to get a sandwich on wonderful bread. I asked for Tuna on Rye and it was so much better than I anticipated! Priced very reasonable and fresh!!! I want to definitely stop in before we hit the road
February 2018 by Lisa E.
Don't bother. Very unfriendly, not particularly clean. As a visitor to the area, bartender definitely makes you feel that you are not wanted -- tried to have us sit in the very back, alone; no offer to get a second round. Patrons didn't seem to have any other command of the English language other than F-bombs. So many other more welcoming places in St. Augustine.
January 2018 by Madison E.
Awesome spot. Small bar and a few tables. Can defiantly get crowed but it's worth it. My roommates, boyfriend, and I meet every Thursday for trivia there. Gina hosts it and she's awesome. We just recently found out about trivia night and it's got us hooked.
January 2018 by Marie P.
We stopped in for Irish coffees and ended up making friends. Warm, friendly pub with excellent Irish coffee, great selection of beers, great service, and the nicest people (staff and customers) around. I regret not eating there. Everyone was raving about the Reuben. We opted for another supposedly Irish restaurant since my husband had a craving for shepherds pie...but they were out of mashed potatoes anyway! We should have just returned to Ann O'Malley's to enjoy good food, great atmosphere and lively conversation. This is a DEFINITE return stop if we visit St Augustine again
December 2017 by Shawn N.
Food was nothing special. Service was friendly but so slow and had to ask for anything extra. Not much of a variety of beers on tap. Overall disappointing.
December 2017 by Brenda B.
I went to this pub for the first time last evening for Kilt Night. There were pipes and drums outside for a bit and live music inside after that. The place was really busy but really fun. The staff are engaging and the atmosphere is what I wanted a pub to be. Lots of laughing, good beer, good food, and you can't beat men in kilts. There is something on the schedule every day, not always music, but the regulars are inclusive, and I look forward to returning very soon. I would definitely recommend this place.
December 2017 by Karina Petrosky
I am writing a review as I sit in here drinking a beer! We’ve come for the second time tonight as we quickly grabbed a sandwich before going on a tour and they were fantastic. I loved that they were made behind the bar because they’re fresh and fast! There’s live music that is just right on sound so you can jam out and have a conversation at the same time. The drinks are cold and refreshing with a TV right in front of you for sports on all kinds. The owner is super friendly and fun and the staff is accommodating! The prices are great and it’s within walking distance of everything you want in downtown! Definitely come here for a good time!!
December 2017 by Ken M.
Hidden gem in St. Augustine. After several pubs ran out of Ruben sandwiches we gave this place a shot. OMG what a great Ruben along with a tall Black and Tan. Great staff with very good sense of humor. Would definitely stop by again.
November 2017 by Paul G.
Excellent hot sandwiches ,Guinness served right, great prices on everything and tonight is great music with 7 nation founder Kirk McLeod
August 2017 by Skip G.
Great Beef on Wick a staple of a WNY bar. Bartender and sandwich guy were awesome. And there is a bartender from Crystal Beach. Can't go wrong!
July 2017 by Melissa F.
Friendly bartenders, fun atmosphere and great service! Beer/wine only. Worth coming by for sure! We'll be back for the live music we've heard is great too. And they even have some parking next to the building. Interesting: there is a suite upstairs that rents out nightly called Pub Life.
May 2017 by Luci R.
We decided to stop by after reading the reviews and we weren't disappointed! The staff makes you feel welcomed and by the time you leave you feel like family. The Marty sandwich is delicious! So good we went back and had it again the next day and that's saying a lot because there's so much good food in St Augustine. Christine is the sweetest! We can't wait to go back!
May 2017 by Steve A.
Amazing place with an incredible friendly staff! Especially Kristine! Drinks were great and food even better! Fabulous place for cruisers to hang out
May 2017 by Jason T.
My wife and I were in St. Augustine for our anniversary, but dared not miss the Penguins in the Stanley Cup Playoffs. We spent Saturday and Monday night with David the bartender at this awesome pub. The live music was excellent, but the attention and service we received from David, even as he was getting slammed, was well above the bar standard. Whenever we make it back to the oldest city, you better believe this will be our pub of choice for good craft beer, pub fair, and the best service!
April 2017 by Jeanette V.
Love love LOVE this place. DAVID the bartender is the absolute best. He had great recommendations and is also a GREAT chef ( lighter museum, wink wink) I recommend here before all!
Thanks for the hospitality! Be back soon!!
January 2017 by Suzan H.
You have to understand our 'travel agreement.' We always have to locate an Irish pub to have a Guinness in. Doesn't matter if we are in St Augustine or Beijing, and Irish pub is on our 'to do' list.
Walked in and we immediately heard English and Irish accents. If they hang here we know were are going to like it. Ordered a Guinness and an IPA, both on tap. Guinness was a proper pour and in the proper glass.
Looking around it isn't particularly Irish. Nice copper bar. Some tables to sit at if you choose to eat. There is a nice porch and outdoor seating available. All in all it is a quaint little place.
The bathrooms were clean. It is attached to a gift shop full of a World of Trinkets. Prices were fair and staff was friendly. We would return.
It looks like it is attached to a bed and breakfast and they offer sandwich and drinks included in the daily price. It also includes off street parking. Quaint little rooms from the looks of them on the internet. Cost is fair given what it includes.
December 2016 by Arnab D.
Food and drinks were good as expected and everyone was really nice. Only cons will be the service which was a bit slow, although I won't complain as I watched whole second half of a premier league game while enjoying the food.
October 2015 by James F.
This place is a Bills Backers bar. Beef on Weck was just like home. Points for having Genny Cream Ale as well.
Only knock on this place was the space.
Until some space opened up, we awkwardly stood behind the small bar while the staff was trying to get around.
Only about 5 tables and a small bar inside, a few tables on the front patio is nice too.
The atmosphere was just like home.