Very small but endearing. Great selection and taste. Friendly, helpful staff. Definitely recommend for that small shop feel with original flavors and tastes.
August 2023
The shop & ice cream are great. However the guy working the counter today @ 3pm needs some more training on customer service. Not friendly at all and rude.
August 2023
this was a good place! i had the kiddie size cookies and cream. very good! friendly service too. i sat down by the window with the little table.
Penny Lick Ice Cream Company was founded in 2013 with the mission of bringing back old-fashioned, custard-based ice cream.
We believe that the best ice cream is the simplest. That means dairy from local cows treated ethically, sustainable whole food ingredients, no artificial flavors or colors. Plus, we never use peanuts, tree nuts or sesame, so everyone can enjoy our ice cream.
We cater! From weddings to graduations, showers to bar/bat mitzvahs, school celebrations and more, Penny Lick is proud to be a memorable part of your special day. Our courteous staff will happily scoop ice cream sundaes and cones for your guests out of one of our adorable and eye-catching push carts!
