March 2019 by Irfan Suli
The best Pizza I have ever had in upstate NY, I drove 25 min to pickup my food from this location... place looks really clean good prices fresh food. I’ll be back
March 2019 by Jeremy Cooper
Huge slices. Good prices. Friendly atmosphere. Will definitely stop by again when in the area.
March 2019 by Brittany Orlopp
The food is great but you definitely lost my business tonight. Waited well over an hour for food. You guys close at 10:00pm and today is a Saturday and which you do close at that time. I placed my first call at 9:45pm to see where my order was and they did not answer. So I proceeded to call until they answered. After the third call I made they kept picking up and hanging up. Finally some rude guy picked it up and I said I made a call well over an hour ago for my food. Well apparently the delivery guy was calling my phone to let me know he was at my door. I did not receive no call or have missed calls on my phone. He probably did try to call but went to voicemail because i had to continuously call because nobody would answer or you would pick up and hang up! AND AGAIN you guys close at 10:00 not 9:45pm. Maybe if you answered my call the first time at 9:45pm the delivery guys phone call would have went through. Never again will i order from this place due to the rude man who answered the phone getting cocky saying the delivery driver was trying to call me when infact it was their fault for not answering and keep hanging up on me. The delivery driver fell down the stairs at my apartment building and I truly hope he is ok. I paid him a $7 tip because I felt bad he had fell. But that will be the last bit of money you guys will ever get out of my pocket. A call to corporate will be made first thing in the morning!!
March 2019 by Andrew Loomis
This place is awesome and so much fun. Customer service is so nice and the food is terrific. It's practically impossible to leave this place unsatisfied. 👍👍
March 2019 by Sarah Polito
Their breakfast pizza is amazing along with all their other pizzas
March 2019 by katherine webb
Fast friendly staff. Food was great
March 2019 by J. Joslyn
Decent priced pizza option in a town over saturated with pizza places.
January 2019 by Alphonse Lucchese
Excellent food. Their sausage sub is the best
January 2019 by La'retta Castro
Great food and customer service.
January 2019 by Thomas Patterson
Food is good but they messed up our order 2 times in a row. Over priced as well.
November 2018 by Michelle L
Very reasonable and excellent food for the price. Most definitely be the place to dine.The staff is friendly and in an convenient location.
April 2018 by John Hayslett
They had the best Sicilian Deep Dish Pizza! I have ever had in my life 😁
March 2018 by Mary
Good size portions great owners
February 2018 by Michelle Coon
Great pizza. Cozy seating
February 2018 by Ja Red
Not as good as the other Salvatores. Never had a good experience here. The wait times are ridiculous. Ive tried the subs and pizza and will find food elsewhere. I would not eat here if it was the only place open. There are much better pizza places in Newark to eat at.
January 2018 by Desiree P.
I have been ordering pizza here for a year and I loved it. They offer triple cheese as an option and as someone who loves cheese I get this every time. Recently there has been an issue that despite paying for triple cheese I am clearly not getting triple cheese by the standards of what I have received for over a year. The first time was clearly that the employees gave me the wrong pizza. They remedied the issue and I was happy. The second time when we went back the employee said "it will probably be greasy with all that cheese" And yet it still wasn't triple cheese. I ordered again today. Again not triple cheese, it appears to be the standard amount. We call and the gentleman who answered the phone said he is the owner and that is triple cheese. Clearly they have no set standard. I don't like to complain and I could see it if I came up with the whole "I want triple cheese" order but they offer it and I willingly pay the extra every time and there pizza isn't cheap. (Not that it has to be) I think if you aren't going to sell it as you give an option for it than don't offer that option. And like I said, I like their pizza I just don't understand how suddenly a year later things are completely different.
May 2017 by amy fernaays
Very friendly service. Was greeted and given menus. Received amazing full service! Food was hot and delicious. Will come back :)
January 2017 by sailorman43
We've eaten at Salvatore's many times and had very delicious food every time... everything is great!
January 2017 by Sue P.
Although the mozzarella sticks are to die for , they need to get another person to do chicken wings , they are soooooooooo over done their unedible. Spent 20 dollars on an order last night , and could only choke down 4 of the 10 wings . This is the 2nd time this had happened. No more
September 2014 by John F.
I've gone to this location twice, been to a few other ones too. Really not a fan of the service here. The girls were too busy chatting to help me, so a third employee came over after I stood there a while. He had a good attitude but wound up over charging me and entering my sandwich incorrectly. When I brought the sandwich back up, one of the girls came up and told me, "that's not what was put in" as if I was lying about a mistake being made. So I spent most of what remained of my break waiting some more. The sandwich had patches that had an off, mold-like taste so even if I had the time to finish, I didn't want to. Overall, I like Salvatore's food, and I like this location's interior. But the employees have a bad attitude more often than not and even the food has been no good half the time. I'm not going to give it a third try.
May 2014 by Craig W.
Wow! What a sandwich. The bread was fantastic and the meat High quality. We stopped in while at the NCAA Baseball tourney and ordered sub's. The Italian mixed was the bomb! Great value for the size you get and great service by the "Boyz" at the counter. Also you have to try the house pizza with the sweet and sour sauce with chicken! Never had anything like it before but you will want it again. Thanks for a great lunch!
September 2013 by Nicole S.
This was my first time ever at a Salvatore's. The staff was cordial and my order was ready upon pick up, they were prompt upon my entrance into the restaurant as far as acknowledging I was there. The sub I ordered was delicious and the boneless wings were crispy just the way I like them. It was lunch hour in a busy part of town so service was excellent based on that. Definitely love the eclectic menu and appearance of this location. Too bad google maps put it on the wrong side of the road. Only thing I didn't get was blue cheese with my wings but no big deal.
September 2013 by Billy K.
Forget this place i have nothing but bad times here first issue was the driver was drunk and was super loud woke my son up! second my sandwich had mold on it ill post a pic . And the only thing they offered to make it right was a another sandwich will not ever return!!!!!! Suggest you all do the same !!! And before the sandwich deal it took a hour and ten mins for a sub as well as fries ANGRYYYYYY !!! Never once went out of there way to fix it
August 2013 by Julie M.
I'm relatively new to the gluten-free scene, and I know that there are some things that just don't translate well into gluten-free recipes. However, having recently been to another pizza place, I know that gluten-free pizza can be done VERY well. Interestingly enough, it wasn't even the gluten-free crust that was terrible, don't get me wrong, it wasn't great but it was edible. Had the rest of the pizza not been of such poor quality, then you wouldn't be getting this review today. So, the gluten-free crust is very thin, and was unevenly cooked. I can overlook that. They don't specialize in gluten-free, it's just an option that they offer to make us dietary challenged people feel included. What I can't overlook is the burnt pizza sauce which was slathered in a layer thicker than the pizza crust, weighing down the dough and making it impossible to eat as a slice of pizza. Yes, I said burnt sauce. Like they left it on the stove for about 3 hours too long, and over-reduced it. Behind the counter wasn't the usual guys we see if we go in at night. It was a couple of replacement girls, who started out the conversation with "we are closed" at 8 pm. I don't think they were thrilled to have to make a specialty pizza. My dining companion, also known as my work partner, wouldn't even eat the gluten-free pizza. So, he went back inside and got a couple of slices. They were the nastiest, dried out slices I have seen in awhile. I've never had a bad experience here before. Hoping this is an isolated event.
January 2013 by Daniel C.
Jay has hit a home run here! I think I visited this location every day that I was home in November 2012. The food is very good and the place looks amazing!!! Jay was very selective in hiring his staff...they are very friendly and helpful! Can't wait to get back there again!!!