May 2020 by James R.
Salvatore's is always a place for great food no matter what you're looking for. My wife likes salads with grilled chicken and finds theirs to consistently be fresh and packed with all sorts of goodies. I like their pizza's and tried their sandwiches which are excellent as well. Service is always friendly and helpful, can't ask for more really.
May 2020 by Scott M.
Probably one of there nicer looking locations that I've seen around the Rochester area surprisingly. Since it's in a rather small population area like Newark. I've ordered there wings and pizza mostly. There wings are decent and there pizza out here was pretty good actually. I ordered the supreme and it comes with a hefty amount of toppings and it's a little bit of a money saver in comparison to getting a large and adding all of the toppings individually. You can also get beer or wine here I'm pretty sure.
May 2020 by C D.
This place is the most disgusting place in Newark, NY. Ordered a Swiss Mushroom burger what did I get? A burger sub with shaved mushrooms on only part of the sub. The taste...well I hate Burger King, this taste worse than there. The fries were burned. Overall disgusting and I wouldn't even serve my dog this food. I have given them so many chances with food and every single time it is so disgusting, burned, tasteless and gross. Not to mention the next day I'm usually very stomach sick!!!
May 2020 by Kristi H
Used to love coming here when mr. Avery owned it. This new owner doesn't care about customer service. Everytime I order the phone girls are rude and always out of product. The prices have increased for a smaller portion. Used to love the ribs now I will never order from here again.
April 2020 by Cody Heck
The food is always good here and the staff is very friendly. I have a lot of bad luck with them either not having what I order online or the order isnt correct when I get it. They are always super apologetic and rectify the situation immediately, but it seems like it happens everytime I order.
April 2020 by Bailey Lamphier
Always very friendly and food is delicious!
April 2020 by Ashley Lane
Order came cold and super late. Then meal had 1 missing chicken finger. Every other time I've had great service until tonight.
March 2020 by lori LeBlanc
The food was great and so was the service.
March 2020 by Jason Doty
Great pizza way better then Mark's
February 2020 by Katherine Venus
Fix your hours on the website. Says opened til 11 and allowed us to order at 10:02 on a Saturday. The last time we ordered here, you were out of multiple things and we had to change our order. Two out of two annoying experiences here. Shame.
February 2020 by Dorrie Dunham
We ordered hot meatball sub and a turkey sub. Delicious!!!! The meatball sub best ever. The sub rolls are perfect ! Great service very clean inside. We will be regular customers.
February 2020 by Jeremy Lloyd
Super happy with this location! As with all Salvatores, it was super clean top to bottom including the rest room. I always wanted to try their steak sub and I'm glad it did. It was superb! They must use a good quality beef and the roll was amazing. I wouldnt hesitate to try it again.
January 2020 by Scott Carnefix
Best pizza in New York
January 2020 by Dan LaGasse
Pizza was the best we've had in a long time. We ate in. Did not like that they only offer bottled drinks - no fountain drinks.
November 2019 by Tomb Stone
Good pizza slices.
October 2019 by David Santelli
The Delivery Person went the extra Mile in going back and. to Bring me the right size soda they had made a mistake and I offered him a tip and he told me that's okay you don't owe me a tip this is Good example of the kind of People we should be more thankful to have in life Cause there's not many of them around.
October 2019 by Bad Review
A sub is meant to have meat in it. When you wait an hour for your dinner to be delivered you are craving a nice large sub with meat! When mine arrived there was enough meat for a small sub when I ordered a large! Can’t tell you how disappointing it was to open the sub I had been craving for over an hour! I hope that the manager is able to train their employees to avoid Pissing off someone else with their sub. Won’t be ordering from Newark Salvators again. I don’t recommend it if you are looking to be full!! After I had what little bit of sub I got I had to make something else to fill me up.
August 2019 by Chris LaDelfa
Delicious sheet pizza, perfect for a party!
August 2019 by Chin Sack
For $8, the burgers are on the small side. Taste good, but are just to small.
July 2019 by Rebecca Timmerman
Kayla is an amazing person. Very polite knows how to be in customer service. I will definitely be back.
June 2019 by Buddy Chasteen
Best pizza in Rochester area, great Italian subs too
June 2019 by Debbie Shuryn
I really like their pizza sauce!
June 2019 by Jeff Patchen
We'll run and customer focused
May 2019 by Tami Godfrey
Great service! The manager treats us like a friend! Feel very welcomed by him and his staff..always excellent service!
May 2019 by Chuck Huff
Awesome steak and cheese subs. Staff are friendly.
May 2019 by kirk leach
"We make any sub into a wrap" translates to here's 4 bites for 10$. Always felt this place is way overpriced but today will be the last time i give them my business.
March 2019 by EMT4444
We use this pizza place all the time at work and the people rave about the pizza. I have never heard one person say they did not like Salvatore's
March 2019 by Irfan Suli
The best Pizza I have ever had in upstate NY, I drove 25 min to pickup my food from this location... place looks really clean good prices fresh food. I’ll be back
March 2019 by Jeremy Cooper
Huge slices. Good prices. Friendly atmosphere. Will definitely stop by again when in the area.
March 2019 by Brittany Orlopp
The food is great but you definitely lost my business tonight. Waited well over an hour for food. You guys close at 10:00pm and today is a Saturday and which you do close at that time. I placed my first call at 9:45pm to see where my order was and they did not answer. So I proceeded to call until they answered. After the third call I made they kept picking up and hanging up. Finally some rude guy picked it up and I said I made a call well over an hour ago for my food. Well apparently the delivery guy was calling my phone to let me know he was at my door. I did not receive no call or have missed calls on my phone. He probably did try to call but went to voicemail because i had to continuously call because nobody would answer or you would pick up and hang up! AND AGAIN you guys close at 10:00 not 9:45pm. Maybe if you answered my call the first time at 9:45pm the delivery guys phone call would have went through. Never again will i order from this place due to the rude man who answered the phone getting cocky saying the delivery driver was trying to call me when infact it was their fault for not answering and keep hanging up on me. The delivery driver fell down the stairs at my apartment building and I truly hope he is ok. I paid him a $7 tip because I felt bad he had fell. But that will be the last bit of money you guys will ever get out of my pocket. A call to corporate will be made first thing in the morning!!