March 2019 by Sylvia Jandreau
I've been ordering from Tolleson's for well over a year. I have never had a bad experience and customer service is always excellent. The Godfather pizza is my favorite and is very unique. I bring my grandsons here and they love coming down to see the pizza man.
March 2019 by Chuck Mundry
The godfather pizza was incredible. So many flavors all mixed in one pizza. Cheeseburger pizza is also fantastic.
March 2019 by David Tulley
Not worth the price i like BBs
February 2019 by Sylvia Jandreau
Every time I order and have it delivered my food is always hot and fresh. Always delivered within under an hour. I appreciate the good service and drivers are always polite.
February 2019 by Laura Craig
No matter how large your order is they charge you for plates and napkins . my cousin called talk to owner about what happened and he was yelling and was very rude at her. very poor customer service . my cousin talk soft and just felt bad serivce was given . if u want to be treated with respect don't order from here.
January 2019 by Cheryl Henninger
A hometown business - great food, great workers, quick delivery...and did I mention the GREAT FOOD?? Tolleson's Pizzeria HAS to stay!
January 2019 by Tim Johnson
Very rude employees. They treat you like you're beneath them just because you're not aware of items in their menu or their way of business. Pizza was alright, but the poor service ruined the experience. Recommend going to one of the many other pizzerias in Newark. See other reviews about poor service. No surprise the one start bar is so high.
October 2018 by Stephanie Smith
Tonight was the first night I order from this place the man on the phone was kinda rude said it was gonna be 40 minuets bc I live out in Fairville which is fine it was over a hour before my food arrived which is also fine my food was cold the wings were slimy and the fried mush tasted like they were cooked in old oil I’m sure my sub would have been good if it wasn’t cold
September 2018 by Cheryl Henninger
Fresh made pizza, saucy wings!
September 2018 by The Animated Mudkip
My dad owns the place so I should know
April 2018 by Brooke Emily
Building could use some TLC. Slices are huge. Prices fair.
December 2017 by Zelda Faye
Staff here is very helpful, sweet, let me and my friend sample a piece of their "God father" pizza. And it was so delicious!
You have to try it! Very much worth it!
November 2017 by Taylor Murray
This pizza is always delicious. It's really hard to spot this place because it's next to a laundry mat, it may look funky on the outside of the building, but I'm telling you this is the best pizza I've had in a long time. I really hope this place can stay in business against the other well known competitor's who's pizza is just okay. They also offer fish frys and those are yummy to. Try this place out you won't regret it.
November 2017 by Jeremys Doppleganger
Spent the day with the owner watching the Bills game and talking about the shop. Ordered pizza and wings tonight and it was absolutely fantastic! Top notch! By far the best pricing in town!
November 2017 by Brian Atwell
Awesome sauce. Just love the whole menu
November 2017 by Susan Chaffee
Ordered $75 worth of food to be delivered. After over an hour, I called. Was told the food was there, they attempted delivery, no one answered the door and tried calling multiple times - no calls received or showed up as missing. All they did was argue with us. They did deliver cold food.
Did you check your manager's phone and the driver's phone for calls made. If they saw people inside, it would have been at a picture window at the side door that has a motion sensor light. The light turns on 1/2 way up the driveway. I do not believe your driver was at the correct house nor did they try to call. AND you never responded to the letter I wrote you. Guess you do not believe in servicing your clients.
March 2017 by Keith L.
Ordered a pizza wings and a salad when I called they stated that got busy and it would be an hour for delivery I said that was fine. After and hour and a half I call back and speak with the same guy and he says sorry I haven't even started to make your order we're busy and there's only two guys working. I told home cancel my order as I am on the phone with Pontillos they call back and say your order is just coming out of the oven now. I again say I don't want it. The fact that no one called and when I questioned why it took so long the guy acted like I should be ok with it is not right. In the past I have had good food but the service sucks! I will be calling the owner tomorrow.
October 2016 by Clara W.
Stopped in while doing laundry next door for a slice. Pizza was good and service was friendly.
May 2015 by Donna H.
I have never ordered from there. From the way the owner takes care of the outside of the building I would be afraid to eat the food. It looks like a dump. If he would take some pride in his business and spruce it up, I'd consider it. I would have given 0 stars but it wasn't an option.
October 2014 by Amy Huber-McGahen
The godfather pizza is amazing! !!! Great food and service! !! And the smores bites are to die for!!!!!!Lol a little disappointed that you aren't able to have seating, but the food is terrific and prices are reasonable so I don't mind taking it home to eat it! !!
July 2014 by Foodfinatic011
I have eaten her le multiple times, but will not return! I have gotten sick on multiple occasions from their wings! The consistency of their pizza is non-existent. One day it will be spot on and then the next it has too much cheese and too many bubbles.