January 2020 by Luke Render
Delicious. One of two locations. This particular location I believe has been there over 30 years. Owner and founder I believe is Tom Carbone. No coffee available. Location is clean, well kept, and smells fantastic.
January 2020 by David Knapp
There are very few things consistent these days, especially in the food industry, but Carbone's is one of those very few places that remain. The food remains consistently outstanding and prices reasonable. While there is often a wait, it's worth it. That is actually a good thing, as they are busy most of the time, and that is due to the the above. I know I am willing to wait for great food; just call it in a little earlier.
December 2019 by Andrew O'Brien
Delicious food. Best blue cheese dressing anywhere.
November 2019 by hugh hemmerich
BEST PIZZA IN THE WORLD. ide Pay 100$ Per pizza if I had to. Anyone who writes negative reviews and complains about carbones is overly sensitive and needs mental assistance . Anyway best pizza on planet earth.
November 2019 by Jim M.
I don't know who was makin the pizzas tonight but they need to go back to pizza school. I have been happy with many purchases there but tonight was really poor quality...soggy crust, sauce tasted different from in the past, just a messy concoction that I had to eat with a knife and fork as it was too soft to pick up. so disappointing compared to past pizzas from there...... jim m
September 2019 by Mary Fox
Menu is so out of date! Picked up my order and it was $20 more than should have been according to site. Garlic wings dry, charged $2 extra each for 2 styrofoam containers for wings. Not a word when we called order in. Lived here for 30 years, always the place to go - not anymore prices crazy, food gone downhill, kids working don’t care. And don’t (never have) delivered.
September 2019 by Michael Pavone
The best Pizza in Rochester!! Need to get them to deliver!!!!
July 2019 by Chelsea Bauman
BEST Oven PIZZA IN ROCHESTER
June 2019 by Carrie Blue
I can't express how awesome the pizza here is! They don't deliver, but picking it up is 100% worth it! Lunch special for $7 includes 2 large pieces of pizza and a 20 oz soda.
June 2019 by Carl Picone
I love their pizza but I recently took a star away because they wont accept coupons unless they are printed out. I dont currently have a printer and so I wasn't able to use the coupon. It's not like each coupon has its individual barcode. Very disappointed that they wouldn't accept this.
June 2019 by Cara Hall
Best pizza in Rochester. And amazing wings! Wish there was one in Gates, but I'll drive to other locations bc it's so good!
June 2019 by Anthony Palozzi
Amazing pizza!! The sauce is so good and the wings are delicious
May 2019 by Jenna Jenkins
If there was anything less than one, that would be my rating. After driving 20 minutes there and 20 minutes back, we arrive home to find out that we were given the wrong pizza. After calling to discuss the options we were told that we could either drive all the way back to return the opened pizza (probably to be given to the next person) or be given a $5 credit on our next purchase, although the pizza alone was $40. To top it off, we were also hung up on by the manager. Definitely the worst pizza customer service in the area and will not be ordering ever again.
May 2019 by Diana Stepp
So.... just had my son pick up a sheet pizza from Carbones for my bday and when he brought it home it had the wrong toppings on it.. Carbones solution... $5.00 of my next pizza (sheet pizza was $36.83) or return the pizza and they will make a new one (60 minutes later)..uhm we are not in the area.. about 20 mins away..how about offer me a free sheet pizza in the future or something equivalent.. $5.00 off, really??? And best part is the pizza does not even taste good..very dissatisfied with outcome, horrible, horrible, unprofessional, terrible customer service. Highly recommend better customer service.. pizza places are a dime a dozen...oh and they hung up on me..kudos to Carbones, ha!
May 2019 by Miller Hammond
Both the pepperoni pizza and white pizza were great.
May 2019 by Marc A Schreiber
Very good food, wings are also very good.
April 2019 by Lydia Kociuba
Best pizza in Rochester. So worth the drive to pick it up!
February 2019 by Dawn Botting
Hot pizza nice people
January 2019 by Jony Manelyuk
Best Pizza and wings in the 585! White sauce pizza is is excellent! Great prices too. Never any issues!
December 2018 by Monroe BOCES
Ironically it tastes better than the Hilton location
November 2018 by christopher horswell
it's pretty good. The staff at this location is awesome. Fast service and great atmosphere.
November 2018 by Robert LaPlaca
BEST PIZZA IN ROCHESTER! Fresh, ingredients, always hot, and family owned.
November 2018 by Mike Hurley
A classic at our house, always great Pizza & Wings!!!
October 2018 by Michael Maffett
Pizza is a subjective thing. This is my favorite pizzeria. Never had a bad pie! No delivery, worth the drive! Unless you're driving from Scottsdale, AZ!
September 2018 by Nick Bakolas
Both the pepperoni pizza and white pizza were great. The white pizza was probably the best I ever had. The wings were large and very tasty as well. Usually pizza shop wings are small, but these were some jumbo wings cooked to perfection!
September 2018 by UrbanMedic007
This has become our weekly pizza stop. Love the white pizza with pepperoni! The blue cheese is also a favorite! Always order an extra or 2 for leftovers!
August 2018 by Rhiannon Johnson
I have been eating Carbone's Pizza for 25 years!! We use to order from the one in North Greece as well as the Hilton one. It's really good pizza! Thin Crust and Real Pepperoni! ðŸ•ðŸ•
May 2018 by Marc Lattimer
it took them a hour and 25 min for a sheet pizza not cool
January 2018 by Paul Hinkley
Always late!! If the food wasn't good I'd never cone back
January 2018 by Daniel Milbrandt
Great tasting pizza and wings. Prices are better than other pizza places. I drive out of the way to go there.