-
July 2022 by Krystal Miles
I am only giving the 1 star because I had to. Very disappointed that they are never open. Per their website their hours are never right. Company would order more from them if they answered their phones.
-
June 2022 by les holcomb
Almost as good as Nimas in Clifton Springs. If you are planning on dining in, I would recommend Fat Boys over Nimas because Nimas is very hot inside
-
March 2022 by Gary Case
Did not go there went next door to drug store
-
March 2022 by Zach Smith
A hidden gem in the town of Phelps! Great pizza (haven't tried the wings or subs... yet) and the owners are very friendly and hard-working people. They have always been super responsive and helpful when I call or stop in, the inside is very clean, and the atmosphere is everything you'd expect ina pizza shop. As someone who worked in a pizza shop for over 5 years growing up, I know how hard it can be to run this type of business and Rick and Tina do an amazing job at it. Definitely recommend giving them a try if you haven't already!
-
February 2022 by Eljay K
I try assorted subs from many different places. I live in buffalo and there is no shortage of pizzerias to order from. FayBoys assorted sub is one of the best I've had. So good!
-
February 2022 by Holy Diver
Staff was nice but the pizza tasted like cheap ingredients were used. The chicken wings were amazing though which is why I gave it more stars.
-
October 2021 by Cindy Meckley
Very good pizza and good service
-
September 2021 by Stephen Verstreate
Couldn't say much haven't been there in a very long time
-
September 2021 by Michael Bailey
Great slices.
-
August 2021 by Team Gutter Squad
Pizza was tough. Greasy and very bland give it 1/10. After two slices my jaw hurt from chewing. The gas station down the road has better pizza.
-
March 2021 by WildWorldFoods
*FIVE STARS* BEST ? NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA! LOVE THE FATBOY ? BURGER!FOOD AND SERVICE ARE GREAT!
-
January 2021 by charlie the kobold
this is my favorite place whenever I am feeling down they always cheer me up also helps that the food is amazing this place should have at least 4 stars if not 5
-
January 2021 by Ken Lendeck
Boneless chicken wings crispy and perfect, garlic pizza ,outstanding.
-
December 2020 by Kiara knaak
Every time I try to call and order food, the place is always closed. I just tried calling at 7:25. They close at 8, nobody answered the phone. If your gonna close early put that on your website.
-
December 2020 by Jarrod Turner
1st attempt: On a Wednesday at noon, called twice, nobody answered phone.2nd attempt: On a Thursday at 1230, woman answered, asked if she could place me on hold, I held for 15 minutes until I gave up.3rd attempt: Happened to be in Phelps at 230, stopped in. Closed for the entire week.4th attempt: Called on a Tuesday at 530, no answer.All about supporting small businesses, but do y’all actually sell pizza?
