-
March 2024 by eric ellison
Awesome Italian style
-
January 2024 by Zach Abugov
If you want to die young while eating something dripping with week-old frying oil, try the deep fried pizza roll. If you want to live, have the lasagna.
-
December 2023 by Janet Delosh
This was the worst pizza I have ever gotten from Sergi”s restaurant it was delivered because I didn’t have a vehicle at the time. The only way to get a replacement was for to take it and show the manager it was burnt. Yeah, right I won’t be ordering from here for sometime.
-
December 2023 by Brad Sherrick
Their pizza is AMAZING! I honestly don't know how other pizza places in that area survive. To eat it fresh and hot right there in the restaurant was perfect.
-
December 2023 by Corie Locke
They have a deep fried calzone. Make sure to get extra sauce but you will also eat it the next day!
-
December 2023 by Zachary Remian
Our waitress was very busy but very good.No straws the sodas not sure if that's the normOur salads were wiltedBread rolls were hard.Ravioli was decent to me, but the wife described it as a frozen dinner that was slid onto her plate.My chicken Parm was okay, thin chicken slice with lots of breading.Deserts we're okay.We paid in cash and it took forever to get the change. The poor waitress was not at fault. She had to wait to be able to cash out our check
-
November 2023 by Joyce Ruocco
Linda was great! Pleasant and overworked! Chicken parm was delicious, chicken marsala was not good. The mushrooms were thrown onto the chicken cutlets. They were not cooked properly and blended with the chicken cutlets, so this is a dish to stay away from. Eggplant was good. Overall. A good local place.
-
November 2023 by Wayne S
Visiting from Canada, looked up reviews and decided Sergi's would be most authentic. Excellent pepperoni pizza! Will definitely return next time we visit Potsdam.
-
November 2023 by Heather Robinson
Was disappointed with the quality of the chicken on the Alfredo and the wings were very dry.The zucchini fries were wonderful.The service and atmosphere was terrific.
-
October 2023 by Joe
Old school pizza place with awesome food. Service was very friendly. The ambiance is that of an old school pizza place. The 2 cheese pizzas tasted great, one was a little under cooked and the garlic bread was phenomenal.
-
September 2023 by Laura LePage
The eggplant parm was delicious. My husband had the chicken parm which he enjoyed just as much. They serve wine and beer.
-
September 2023 by Brian Meifert
My favorite pizza place in Potsdam. I used to order from Sergi's when I went to SUNY Potsdam, and like to order from there when bringing our oldest up to Clarkson. The wings and pizza are as good as I remember.
-
August 2023 by Jason Purdy
What a great team at Sergi's .. very customer focused and go over and above to satisfy!Thanks for the great Pie ?Jason from Halifax ... I will be back soon ...
-
August 2023 by MaloneNYtraveler
Another trip to Potsdam, another trip to Sergi’s. Can’t go wrong here, have never had a bad meal. Owners always on site, server’s are great. Very convenient to both colleges in Potsdam, and another Sergi’s down the road just 10 miles in Canton. Stop at Sergi’s you won’t regret it!
-
August 2023 by Scott Schluter
Great Hawaiian pizza. Thick crust. Great pizza rolls, dunno why they aren't calzones and available with all pizza toppings.