Been coming here for the last 10 years with my family and have always had pleasant experiences. The coffee is the arguably the best in New York and I highly recommend getting the chocolate covered s’more. The hamptons wouldn’t be the hamptons without Sylvester’s.
September 2021
This store is the most important store in sag harbor because it has Dreamy Coffee on tap in the back. I’m not even going to tell you what Dreamy is because you should experience it as a surprise. Speaking of surprises - this is a great store for specials gifts.
December 2020
Just received a private message from this “classy” establishment. Lol. Unbelievable. I won’t repost it. Funny,the visible answers to your bad reviews seem that they almost care about the customer.
We are OPEN to the public with limited capacity -- masks required. We are also still offering online ordering for in store and curbside pick up. Can't wait to see you!
