January 2021 by Rick Lacroix
They have the best calzones and pizza I have ever had. The owners and staff are super friendly. We travel a half an hour to get their food and it’s well worth the drive..
November 2020 by 13shadylady13
Hadn't been in the area or to this place in decades still great prices and great food.
November 2020 by Adam Thomas
Sandwich was good and they got me in and out when I was pressed for time.
August 2020 by Franco Z
My sister in law lived above this place in college. When we would visit it was a must to get some pizza here. Good food.
July 2020 by Truxxton ..
Called and ordered 2 pizzas, got there, looked in, 6 people working, NO ONE WAS WEARING MASKS. ZERO SOCIAL DISTANCING. Including 2 customers before me, one of them was leaning over the counter talking to the cashier face to face. FACE TO FACE.Called them back and told them we are not going to honoring the order, and the manager told us "masks are NOT required!" And asked us what are they supposed to do with those pizzas?!?! Went to Vermont accd.vermont.gov, and..."Employees must observe strict social distancing of 6 feet while on the job""Employees must wear face coverings over their nose and mouth when in the presence of others. In the case of retail cashiers, a translucent shield or 'sneeze guard' is acceptable in Lou of a mask"There was a COVID hot spot breakout just over a week ago with 11 people infected in the town of Fair Haven which is 6 miles north of Poultney.Will NOT return to any business that doesn't take customer safety seriously like this one.EVER.
June 2020 by Kevin Flynn
Long time owners have pride in their food and community service. Excellent pizza and other choices. Eat in or take out. Normally has 2 tables outside during warm weather. Excellent food and service from this family run establishment.
June 2020 by Michael Pierce
Nothing to write home about. Nice staff, nice crust, but very skimpy toppings (depending on the one(s) you order), unremarkable sauce, and overcooked. In Poultney, options are limited, but if you're nearby, try Ole Hampton House Tavern. It's right down the road.
June 2020 by Robert Isherwood
Great food options across the menu.
April 2020 by Samantha Matteson Dundon
Poultney House of Pizza has the BEST pizza around! My 5 year old is currently battling leukemia and chemo has changed her taste buds on a lot of things. Poultney pizza has remained her favorite pizza throughout and sometimes has been among the small selection of things she is willing to eat. Thank you PHOP for providing consistently good pizza all these years!
April 2020 by Morghan Coltey
Delicious as always. Very clean and offered a safe way to get food during this crazy time. Thanks guys!
February 2020 by John Bass
Their food is always great! Especially lasagna. Its all homemade. Pizza is good and at a reasonable price.
February 2020 by Karen Powers
The pizza was great. People are very nice.
February 2020 by Kylee Elizabeth
My fiancé placed an order and was very specific about what should be on my burger and I got the complete opposite of what I wanted. Definitely will be taking my business elsewhere.
February 2020 by muhammad bilal
Great place for good food and friendly staff
January 2020 by David R. Noel
People are friendly and efficient. We've had their; pizza, calzone, subs, and wings. All of the food was delicious and fresh. Prices are also incredibly reasonably. Strongly recommend!
January 2020 by ruth hayes
Excellent pizza! Great friendly staff! Loved it!
January 2020 by Sue Kinney
Loved the pizza. Small place, very friendly service.
November 2019 by Cindy Fitzgerald
Pizza is great, service is quick, and their staff is super friendly! We usually order every week!?
November 2019 by Jamie Pauquette
Love their pizza and calzones! Great customer service too!
November 2019 by Grammy Fitz
Pizza is great, service is quick, and their staff is super friendly! We usually order every week!
November 2019 by MindyS323
When you live in New York City and Brooklyn, you have access to the finest pizza in the world. Having moved to Vermont when I got married, I was constantly disappointed in the pizza here. At best, it was okay. And then Poultney House of Pizza opened. Excellent pizza. Just like my old home. And the owner is from New York originally....no surprise. ;) Highly recommended. And their heroes are great too.
October 2019 by 11CharlesS
We picked up a pizza the last time we visited and had supper with friends. Very good. We had a Pepperoni and Half Veggie.
October 2019 by Evan Steinert
Great service great food. A must stop place if you're passing through . Live bands are very good too. Some outdoor seating, a large bar, family friendly dining, right in the heart of Poultney. Easily 5 star .
October 2019 by Patricia Devino
Great food and good prices.
October 2019 by Ben Kainen
Awesome food. Love it every time
October 2019 by Adirondack Camping Adventures
Love to eat here every time I am working in the area.
October 2019 by James Kafka
Very good pizza, friendly service and nice atmosphere.
September 2019 by LIV2FLY
On a beautiful September day we were enjoying downtown Poultney and stopped in for lunch. Poultney House of Pizza was a very nice friendly place with quite a few menu options. I had a hankering for pizza and my wife chose a Chef Salad. We sat outside to enjoy the afternoon and when our food came out the pizza looked marvelous. I chose a simple Pepperoni Pizza and it was delicious with a great crust and gooey cheese. My wife’s salad was loaded with deli ham and turkey and she thought it was good. Overall a very good place to eat!
September 2019 by Christine B.
Pricey for pizza - but it's good, and really one of the only places to pick up a pizza or 3!
August 2019 by Shirley E.
Maybe it's because I'm a New Yorker but My husband and I thought the pizza was terrible. Do not go for the pizza maybe other things are better here but the pizza not it