Our server, Maria, was very friendly. She helped us narrow our choices (which are almost impossible to pick just one). Maria was also attentive.The food here is always amazing!
March 2024
The food was AMAZING and the customer service was top tier. Maria was such a sweet server. Definitely will returnVegetarian options: Lots of vegetarian pastas, pizza & appetizers!
March 2024
Great pizza, and the staff could not be any nicer. I tried walking my used plate to the counter and was quickly met with, "You don't need to do that."
We are the ORIGINAL Anthony's NY Pizza of Orlando, founded in 1987 (and the best in town)! When you are craving the best pizza in Casselberry, this is the place! We are YOUR local pizzeria of choice for Casselberry, Winter Park, and Maitland for over 37 years!
We're don't just sell pizza, though - we also have mouth watering chicken wings, pasta, salad, and the best hot and cold subs to fill your gut (without emptying your wallet). Feeling like a chicken parm sub, anyone?
Original Anthony's NY Pizza in Casselberry is honored to be your local pizza favorite. We use only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes, and we offer dine-in, takeout, and delivery options.
Other Information
Parking: Lot, Private
Attire: Casual
Cuisines: Deli, Caterers, Family Style, Italian, European, Continental, Pizza
