Insurance in Lake Mary, FL

17 locations found near Lake Mary

“Nicole is absolutely the best! She is extremely knowledgeable, professional, and incredibly helpful, but what really stands out is her kindness and wonderful demeanor. She makes the entire insurance experience feel easy and comfortable, and her customer service is never short of truly exceptional. You don’t come across people like Nicole every day. 10/10 customer service!!”

5 Superb185 Reviews

“Stephanie was excellent, immediately looked for new Homeowners insurance with the best option and price. She saved me a great deal on a new policy! She is very responsive and provided excellent customer service. Very easy to work with and always responds right away!”

5 Superb104 Reviews

“Every year when insurance time comes around you find me the best match for coverage and cost. I work with Omayra and she has been excellent in ensure best value for my real needs.”

4.9 Superb149 Reviews

“Nashalee was great! she was able to find me full coverage for my Range Rover at a very competitive rate and her great customer service made the process seamless. Ty”

4.9 Superb121 Reviews

“Out of all my years dealing with insurance agencies and owning the same home, I have never spoken with someone as knowledgeable about home insurance coverage as TJ. I originally called after receiving a flyer in the mail, since I always do my due diligence and shop around for homeowners insurance every year before renewal. Usually nobody can beat my current company’s rates, so I honestly didn’t expect much.

Thankfully, I ended up speaking with TJ, and from the beginning she was professional, positive, and genuinely helpful. She treated me the way every licensed insurance agent should treat both potential and existing clients, by making sure they are properly covered and actually understanding their policy.

TJ took the time to review my current homeowners policy and explained things no one had ever pointed out before. She showed me that I had actually been underinsured for quite some time and that there were mistakes and outdated information in my policy that could have caused serious issues if I ever needed to file a claim.

Because of her honesty and attention to detail, I decided to switch companies. The new policy wasn’t necessarily cheaper, but it gave me something more important: peace of mind knowing my home is properly protected. On top of that, she bundled my auto insurance and was able to save me money there as well.

What really stood out to me is that TJ said she will continue reviewing my policies at renewal to make sure everything stays updated and properly covered, something my previous agent never did.

TJ is truly a valuable asset to this agency, and I’m very happy I made the switch. If you want an agent who actually works for you, takes the time to educate you, and makes sure you’re insured correctly instead of underinsured, I highly recommend asking for TJ.”

4.8 Superb45 Reviews

“Absolutely amazing experience with Sungate Insurance Agency! The team was incredibly knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely cared about finding the best coverage for me. They took the time to explain all my options clearly and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I never felt rushed or pressured—just supported every step of the way. Highly recommend to anyone looking for reliable and trustworthy insurance help!”

5 Superb36 Reviews

“I have been using Applied Insurance Services, Inc for over 25 years for business and private insurance services. I have found the company to be reliable and diligent in finding high quality insurance underwriters at reasonable premiums. The fact that I have used their services for so many years is an indication of my satisfaction with their performance.”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“Thanks to AssuredPartners for handling our insurance needs.Amanda makes the process incredibly simple. She is kind, efficient and very responsive! I can't recommend her enough!!”

5 Superb12 Reviews

“Wonderful team of professionals who have helped me with my insurance coverage for auto and home. They really go the extra mile to make sure I get the best insurance coverage possible!”

4.9 Superb12 Reviews

“Thanks the insurance Policy guys!, I acquired It with You and just a few days after I was rear ended while stopped a red light, the other driver was uninsured, Jeez, It wasn´t a high speed crash but thank God, insurance took care of the scratches and dents, quick paint job and back on the road, thanks for the service!”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“Roxanne Bernabe assisted me and was extremely helpful and kind. She was very knowledgeable and helped ensure I got the best service possible for my insurance. Thank you so much Roxanne! You are amazing :))”

4.4 Superb69 Reviews

“Amazing service. White glove-like service. Not to mention Lisa Barton is the most helpful and amazing person I've had the pleasure to speak with. And we have the same last name, just adds to the experience!”

4.3 Superb40 Reviews

“The Carli Agency has been consistently helpful, efficient, patient & understanding with me in assisting with my home insurance needs since 2011. Thanks, folks! : )”

4.2 Good40 Reviews

“Brittany is kind and very helpful. Not only did she directly connect me with my insurance company regarding a claim, she stayed on the the line and provided my policy info to make it an efficient experience.”

4 Good7 Reviews

“Susan Bentley at this CNA branch is such a helpful and above-average employee. If every surety company I dealt with at my job had this supurb level of customer service, it would make my job a lot easier. Kudos!”

3.3 Good10 Reviews

“Ethan with customer service was amazing this afternoon, 4/17, regarding an important change that was needed asap. Very personal and friendly. Highly recommend a company with such great staff.”

2.4 Poor133 Reviews