I Orderen 3 calzones and they all came out burnt at the bottom. I didnt realize until I woke up the next day to try one, as I ordered yesterday for my family and didnt check at all. Now I will. So dissapointed. They look good but they are burnt.
September 2023
Never again! They actually added thier own tip when we used a card! And it was just one pizza!and not a very good one!
August 2023
Under new management and the food has gone downhill. So many things wrong with this place. EAT THERE AT OWN RISK? I recommend Nothing from here!
Don't let the clever name fool you, this Brooklyn New York Pizza is not in New York, it's in St. Natick, and that is a lucky thing for you if you are near St. Natick. Many locals consider it the best pizza in town, and sWear by the homemade pesto. The pizzas gain compliments too, with the Buffalo Chicken and the Sausage and Roasted Red Pepper being among guests favorites.
