“I was in a time crunch and in need of a quick resizing of my wedding band. I haven’t been able to take it off for 15 years and yesterday I tried the floss technique, on a whim. It was 2 days before going on vacation, and I was shocked that it worked!! Needless to say, I did not want to put it back on my finger, but I also didn’t want to go on vacation without my wedding band. Why did I do this right before vacation when I have a million things to do?! A quick search revealed several jewelers in the area, but Elegant Jewelry stood out because of their overwhelmingly positive reviews and the mention that they have been around for many years. Well!!! The reviews were spot on!! In business over 30 years and it was clear why—Arsen is amazing and the rest of the staff are true gems! Not only did Arsen resize my wedding band and make it look like new in an hour, but he also noticed the unpolished state of my engagement ring and offered to quickly make it as beautiful as my wedding band at no additional cost. What a class act! As I was leaving I noticed exactly the pair of earrings I have been searching for, so I will definitely be back with some old trade-in jewelry. I live 40 minutes away and just happened to be in Patchogue for the afternoon, but I will happily make the drive again after my vacation because of the quality of service and the quality of the staff.”
11AM - 6PM
80 Main St, Sayville
Jewelry Stores
“Ricky is awesome! He Came through with exactly what I wanted and did everything he said he would do during the process. Pleasure working with him, I will definitely be back. Thank you!”
“Ronny’s the man!! Picked up a new diamond rolex oyster perpetual datejust today. He worked with me gave me a great deal and had good conversation while getting everything together!! Only shopping with him for now on.”
“Stopped by today not knowing the place was appointment only until I read the sign at the door, but the gentleman at the counter let me in anyway and asked what he could do for me. I needed an install/downsize after my cat ripped my titanium post out of my eyebrow. My temporary replacement was far too long, mystery metal, and really, really irritating my piercing. He squeezed me right in and got me set up with a new piece real quick. VERY clean, VERY professional, very honest. Autoclaved the jewelry right in front of me. Talkative and kind. There’s always a risk of rejection with eyebrows, but I’m happy he was willing to work with me to try and save it. Wish I could remember his name! Affordable pricing before jewelry for one of the only APP shops on the Island. My eyebrow looks and feels better already. So relieved and will be coming back soon for some new holes. Thank you!
TLDR; clean, professional, friendly, accommodating. Price is right. Would recommend.”
“I love that I can “stop in” on my way to any party, today being a bridal shower and get what I need, the most beautiful gifts every time! Favorite shopping I ever do!!”
“Nancy was a great help with picking out my earrings. She was attentive, patient and I didn’t feel rushed. I am so happy with my purchase. thank you so much Nancy!”
“Found this beauty in the MCM booth. I have never had such a good experience with an antique store! The staff was super helpful, and Mike, the owner of the clock, was willing to ship this for me! I live in Florida and saw the clock on a Facebook post. If you are ever in the area, definitely check this place out!”
10AM - 5:30PM
48 Main St, Sayville
Jewelry Stores
“Each and every time I shop at this lovely jewelry store, I leave happier and happier. The staff is professional, kind, courteous, and willing to go that extra mile for the consumer. Kelly is delightful and accommodating. I highly recommend this fine jewelry store for your best shopping experience.”
“Went in there today get to my jewlery serviced. I was helped by Artie, he was great, courteous, and assisted me with everything I needed. Definitely recommend this place. Thanks again Artie.”
“We have purchased two flower girl dresses at TiggyWinks now and had fantastic experiences both times. The selection, quality, and pricing were exactly what we were looking for. The service was amazing - the staff is warm and welcoming and flexible if we needed to change sizes closer to the date as kids to tend to grow at this age. Highly recommend going here!!”
“This place is absolutely amazing! I come here every Christmas and also throughout the year. The staff always welcomes me and is always so helpful, especially for a young guy that doesn’t have a woman’s touch on fashion and what’s in and what will look nice! Highly recommended to everyone!”
“First time coming here to get my second lobe done! She explained to me thoroughly the aftercare and recommend me what earrings I should get. It was very helpful, reluctant as I was. Definetly would come here again to get my other lobes done!”
“After an off-putting experience with an OTHER local jeweler, my fiancé & I came to Lamonica Jewelers to have her engagement ring taken down a size. It was beyond refreshing to deal with all the friendly faces we were greeted with. And the work was excellent. You can tell they really care about their business. They are not just out to get your money; coming here feels like coming to a family-friend. You will not regret choosing Lamonica over any other jeweler.”
2 - 5PM 10AM - 1PM
9 Windsor Ave, Brightwaters
Jewelry Stores
“Wow! Went here today with my mom to get my necklace fixed and not only did the jewler immediately know how to solve my problem but he also fixed it on the house! Such an amazing experience. I will be back in the future for any of my jewlery needs!”
“One of the few if only Irish stores left on Long Island with a wide range of beautiful items. Clothing, jewelry, household items, signs, and so much more. One can spend a day here!. The best place to find your Irish gifts !!”
11:30AM - 5:30PM
813 Montauk Hwy B, Bayport
Jewelry Stores
“This little store has a rainbow of beautiful stained glass creations hand made by artists Sandy and her daughter Kathy. Pick a beautifully crafted sun catcher, a piece of unique jewely, or a nightlight, or go big with a stained glass bowl or wall hanging. Sandy and Kathy will even etch a message with a name if you'd like. I love my choice: a map of Long Island on glass made with tiny glass fragments and etched with an anchor and "Long Island "”
“Great staff and excellent service. G is very professional and direct. Excellent custom handcrafted jewelry. Work is done on premises. I had a few watches polished and reconditioned. They looked brand new when i got them back. I highly recommend this place.”
“I want to start off by saying Jen was awesome! I visited about a month ago with my girlfriend to see what rings she might like, and she gave some great insights and tips about rings.
Fast forward a month and I came back, and Jen remembered me. We took a look at the ring I wanted to purchase and we got it all squared away, the process was so easygoing and simple. She was able to price match to the online price, which was about 30% cheaper than the original store price. She easily explained the process all the way through and I feel I made a great choice thanks to great staff at this Zales, including Jen.
5 star service! Don’t buy online when you can get amazing service in person. It’s so worth it!”
10AM - 5:30PM
491 Main St, Islip
Jewelry Stores
“Mazza Jewelry is truly one of a kind. My husband purchased my engagement ring from Mazza and we also bought our wedding bands here. They made every experience so wonderful and so fun. They have a wide selection of beautiful rings and can design engagement rings to be exactly what you imagine. Thank you to all the amazing staff and owner, Diana! We love you guys and are so happy you all are a part of our special memories ♥️”
9:30AM - 5PM
1 E Main St, Patchogue
Jewelry Stores
“I have been having my Rolex Submariner serviced at O’Neill’s in Patchogue for the last 15 years. Always handled professionally and with care and never a second thought about leaving my baby at this 50+ year institution.”
“What happened Saturday March 22 at 12pm. I walked in trying to get my jewelry but someone behind the counter was having an episode. I waited 1 1/2 hours. Didn’t get my stuff. I hope he’s ok.”
“Excellent service, I am I frequent shopper here I been buying gold from this store with all my family members for over 10 years now , and always receive top class customer service by staff. The store manager Gladys is extremely helpful and accommodating. They Sale really nice designs and quality materials in Gold and jewelry , I Highly recommend this store to everyone, if you are Looking to buy a gold or jewelry gift for some you will be very surprised for what they sale . All types of designs you looking for and for a fair Price . ✌?”
“had a very good experience at this claire’s. a little dirty but nothing is ever not dirty. had a very pleasant and enjoyable experience getting helped by rachel. will shop again”
“This is the only place to get your newest summer outfits. The owners are super friendly and make every customer feel welcome, and look great. The styles are one of a kind that you won’t find everywhere else out there or on the main land, and they get new looks in all the time. I especially love all the accessories and beach-ready gear like coolers, bags, sandals, sunglasses and towels. I get compliments all the time on items I pick up from the store. The store also does an excellent job of making it an “experience” shopping there, with fun music, air conditioning!, and accessible changing rooms. The employees are all very patient and want you to be happy with everything you pick out, and they make intelligent suggestions, not just pushing anything. Also, when a few tweens/teenagers were acting like the place was their own private hangout, the staff politely had them move along. Overall, this is a place you have to visit and pick something up, and everyone you know will compliment you on your new items!”