Sporting Goods near Smithtown, NY

28 locations found near Smithtown

“I haven't visited this location for some time. I was impressed by the selection of lacrosse equipment, cleats, and clothing options. The manager was friendly and knowledgeable about the right mouthguard for my daughter with braces. Definitely a nice change to shop at a speciality shop and not get lost in the hunting section.”

4.3 Superb11 Reviews

“check them out at their new temp location! Cant beat shopping local, they were so nice and I left with the most beautiful pair of On Clouds. Never getting shoes anywhere else!”

5 Superb133 Reviews

“The absolute best experience I’ve ever had buying clubs a friendly, experienced, knowledgeable team that will truly help you find the best products for you. They are helpful and always willing to go above and beyond to make sure you leave a happy customer.”

5 Superb77 Reviews

“Had a really great experience at this New Balance location thanks to Mark. He was incredibly knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely helpful without being pushy at all. He took the time to explain the different sneaker options and helped me find the right fit and support for my feet. You can tell he really cares about helping customers rather than just making a sale. He left such a positive impression on us, and we’ll definitely be coming back soon. We’ll absolutely be recommending this store…and Mark specifically, to friends and family!”

4.8 Superb100 Reviews

“A MUST GO location for long island soccer players. They had everything needed to outfit my travel team player & the staff was super helpful. 100% our new go-to for gear!”

4.6 Superb59 Reviews

“Great service. When I placed my order they were out of the sized socks. Received a phone call asking if another size would work. They reassured that with my foot size being "between size" they will fit. The fit was perfect. I was also missing an item and when reported, it was mailed out the next day and was mailed with 4day service.I appreciate service like this.”

4.4 Superb101 Reviews

“I have used Schwabs Second Wind as my go to place for sneakers for the last several years. I am especially difficult to fit given that I have extra wide flat feet, supination, wear custom orthotics and have had 3 major foot surgeries in the last 3 1/2 years.

The team at Schwabs is knowledgeable, patient, informative and professional. They never let you leave until you have footwear that fits well and is appropriate for the conditions unique to each customer. They have custom ordered sneakers for me that upon arrival were not conducive to my needs or interests and never flinch if I ask to try a different product.

My last 3 experiences, Claire has been the person working most closely with me. She is a superstar! After two visits, trying on MULTIPLE style sneakers in various sizes, she and her teammate got me fitted into a pair of Ghost Max 3. They fit amazingly well out of the box and are comfortable even with my custom orthotics inserted.

Thanks to everyone at Schwabs - especially Claire for your patience, knowledge and extraordinary customer service!

See you next time…”

4.8 Superb44 Reviews

“Very helpful staff, even took the sweater I wanted off the mannequin because it was the only one left in stock; fit perfectly too. Overall a great experience and offers a student discount which is amazing.”

4.4 Superb113 Reviews

“I could not be happier with my experience at Carlock's Sportshack. The embroidery done on my pieces was clean, gorgeously done and booming with craftsman ship. Not only did they do an incredible job but they also helped bring the vision to life by making suggestions to make the design even better. Thank you so much to the Carlock's ❤️ Amazing family business with integrity and a smile.”

4.7 Superb42 Reviews

“Needed a new rod and reel, something lightweight for the weakfish my buddies have been catching. I went to this shop for the first time on Saturday and asked the guy behind the counter for some help picking a rod out. He was great! He showed me a nice selection of rods in different prices, and explained to me the benefits of each one. When we got to the reels, Bill showed me a few different ones at different prices and again showed off each one. I had no idea you had to fish this way for weakfish, no wonder I’ve been having such a hard time! Just wanted to say thanks to Bill for getting me set up with the right gear, including lures and bait. He even told me a few spots to try! Came home that night with dinner for the family. Love this shop and I’m a new forever customer.”

4.7 Superb33 Reviews

“The owner, Chase is a great guy & very knowledgeable. My experience with him for my first pickleball paddle has been nothing but great!! You can try to demo as many paddles for as many weeks as you want to before you decide to buy your own.”

4.6 Superb33 Reviews

“Been coming here for seasonal ski rentals for my kids for the past 10 years or so...and my parents took me here when I was a kid too. Very personable customer service for both winter & summer outdoor activities.”

4.5 Superb49 Reviews

“Great staff. I bring my son and daughters here any time we need expert advice. They alway put together products that are custom tailored to my kids playing style. Recently purchased my son a new stick and they asked him a ton of questions to make sure they they string it to fit his needs. Staff is always friendly and super helpful. Prices are on par with any other pro shop.”

4.9 Superb17 Reviews

“5/8/2026 – Tyrell was really helpful and patient. He made my shopping experience great, and the store had a good selection of shoes with good prices. I’ll definitely come back.
5/12/2026 – I came back to the store and Brianna helped me out. She was very helpful, found the right shoe size for me, and confirmed they were in stock.”

4.2 Good55 Reviews

“Must give credit where it’s due not sure if managers take the time to read these but in the event that they do; Noreen was absolutely exceptional and took so much time to assist in the softball department as well as Patrice at the register who was so kind and just as helpful.”

4.1 Good116 Reviews

“Whether you're an experienced bowler, or just starting out and need help with getting your equipment, these guys are absolute best. They take great care and attention making sure everything is perfectly fit to you. Incredibly knowledgeable and a pleasure to talk to as well. Couldn't recommend highly enough!”

5 Superb7 Reviews

“The store manager Khalib (Forgive me if I misspelled it), was amazing . He went above and beyond to assist my son and I. I will definitely be back to spend my money because he showed that customer service is important.”

4 Good41 Reviews

“They have a large variety of shoes. The prices are generally competitive. Although if you're buying a specific brand ( sketchers) that also happens to be right next door, maybe the branded store will have a better deal.”

3.9 Good33 Reviews

“Carla and Sean are the best, they give the best customer service. Carla just did my 7th Yankees cap today with Cody Bellinger #35 Signature and she always does a great job. Sean is amazing too. Thank you Carla and thank you Sean!”

3.8 Good35 Reviews

“I recently visited the Foot Locker at Smithhaven Mall in NY to pick up a couple of pairs of Air Force 1 Pandas, and I couldn't be more pleased with my experience. From the moment I walked in, the staff was incredibly welcoming and helpful. They were knowledgeable about their products and guided me straight to what I was looking for.The store was well-organized, making it easy to browse through their extensive selection. Despite it being a busy day, I didn't feel rushed or ignored. The staff ensured I got the right size and even offered insights into how to best care for the sneakers to keep them looking fresh.Checkout was a breeze, and the overall atmosphere in the store was very positive. It's clear that customer satisfaction is a top priority at this Foot Locker location. I'm thrilled with my new Air Force 1 Pandas—they're exactly what I was hoping for, and the shopping experience made it all the more enjoyable.Kudos to the team at the Smithhaven Mall Foot Locker for their exceptional service and for making my shoe shopping experience memorable. I will definitely be returning for future purchases and highly recommend this store to anyone looking for great sneakers and even better customer service.”

3.8 Good65 Reviews

“Thank you to the staff for your help today. We were in store around 130pm and with their friendly assistance was able to find what we needed and order for delivery what was unavailable in store. We greatly appreciated the service. Happy holidays!”

3.8 Good97 Reviews

“They are the best, they have got the best fleece as well as sweatshirt and sweat pants, however they don't have anyoutlets near smithtown/kingspark/commack. All prices are very fair and they have got the best quality of shoes among all brands.”

3.8 Good101 Reviews

“I would recommend this place 1000% The young lady that helped was super helpful and resourceful. I then met the owners son and he was such a pleasure to chat with. Got everything I needed.”

3.7 Good23 Reviews

“I went to the Columbia clearance store today and Scott and Karen were great! They helped me find all of the products I was looking for and gave excellent service.”

3.7 Good80 Reviews

“This company is fantastic! The poor (and absurd) reviews are coming from salespeople who were asked to leave the premises - well within the rights of the business.”

3.6 Good26 Reviews

“Cris in the shoe department was incredibly helpful and kind with my two sons! He was patient, knowledgeable, and genuinely pleasant to work with.

Ryan at the register was just as wonderful—super helpful and so friendly! Both made our shopping experience a great one.”

3.6 Good98 Reviews

“The price of the merchandise is amazing. I got some good deals. I cant wait to go back again. The prices are the best. I got a tank for like 10 bucks. And a hat which was the best.”

3.6 Good113 Reviews

Related topics