Thrift Stores in Payson, AZ

“Explored lots of thrift stores on this street and this was my favorite by far. Your purchase goes to a great cause and they their prices are VERY fair. The boutique items are a little more pricey than others, but still very reasonable for the quality of product. Found some really cool jackets and a beautiful pair of earrings for only $2.00. The staff was very friendly and I definitely recommend stopping in to benefit the humane society.”

“No sooner than both of my feet were planted firmly inside the door, here at "New Beginnings", I heard two voices say "Hello", not including the voice inside my head, and I answered back "Hello" to them. Now I was wondering if I might have been the 100th customer of the day, they were both so friendly, then they proceeded to tell me that the entire store was 25 percent off. Hmm, the voice in my head said. I said, the entire store? One of the nice ladies said, Yup, and you can buy the store for 25 percent off, if you like.... I laughed,"no thanks, maybe next time", then my quest had begun. The store was very nice and they have some great things to look at and to buy. As I went up and down and all around the ailes, admiring how clean everything was and how many nice things they had, from shoes, to clothing, dishes to nik naks, the voice in my head asked, what are you doing here? 97 percent of everything is for women. I mumbled back, Yeah, but 3 percent isn't, and what do you know, maybe my feminine side wanted to shop, so there. That shut him up, ha. I continued to browse the entire store, still noting how nice this little shop is and "Ding" I found something that really caught my eye. I removed it from the shelf, being careful not to damage it, and then I took my item to check out. The nice woman behind the counter asked, is that it? As she picked it up and then tossed it down on the counter. I cringed, said yup, paid for my item, picked it up off the counter and proceeded to the exit. Goodbye, I heard, thanks for stopping in, I said Bye, you're welcome. Right before I reached the doorknob, she said, "I hope that you enjoy your new ball cap", Thank you, I answered and out the door I went. Boy, I sure do like my new hat!Nice Place, Nice People, y'all should stop in and see what treasures await you!”

“Best Prices with Great Selection and Good Quality Items. 2 bargain barns out back + kids barn and hardware shed. Crazy awesome daily deals.Benefits Meals on Wheels and Seniors of Payson.”

“A very cute store with an amazing staff. Ed will always give you a very fair price. Thank you Peggy for always being willing to carry my stuff out! ?

UPDATE!!! This original review was written about a month ago & I forgot to post it!! I am happy to say the store itself has actually continued to show how wonderful they are!! The employees that have seen me there regularly will always greet me and inquire how I’m doing! Thank you for outstanding customer service Peggy, Sherry, John, Johnathon and especially Ed for your role in keeping things running so smoothly, your genuine conversations with many customers….and for carrying my stuff to the car when it’s heavy! Most of all, the wonderful things you do for the Payson Community and the lives you’ve changed with your unselfish care. Thanks”

“The 2 men were very helpful with my selection and very outgoing. No pressure there. I got a table on sale which surprised me how nice it was for the sale price. It looks great in my home!”

“Surprisingly lively place, the volunteers look like they work hard! They have a good system in place for paying for things with a credit card, which seems like a silly thing to notice, but I've been in my fair share of secondhand stores who don't really have that figured out. Scored an awesome piece of vintage clothing for $10. If you're looking for vintage furniture or housewares, this is a good spot!”

“I go to many Goodwill stores in the valley and this one is by far superior than all of those stores. It is clean and organized and I always find deals. I never leave empty handed!”