Casey's in Bella Vista is a convenience store and gas station offering pizza delivery and pickup. The pizza features made-from-scratch dough, real mozzarella cheese, and fresh toppings. The store also provides appetizers, sweet treats, drinks, household essentials, and groceries. The staff is noted as extremely nice and the store is very clean. One specific positive is that the 91 octane fuel contains no ethanol. However, some customers find the gas is often more expensive than in nearby towns. Opinions on the pizza are mixed, with some calling it just okay for gas station pizza and noting it can be more expensive than other local options. The location on Riordan Road can be difficult for getting in and out of safely. Past amenities like free air and 24-hour access are no longer available. Customer service recovery for delivery mistakes has been unsatisfactory for some.
Your breakfast pizza changed my life. I am going to name my first born “Casey” Thank you
April 2025
Finally somebody gets it!! There are two things that are not real in this world nor will they ever be; Unicorns and a man that can aim when we pee. It’s just not possible! So having these as urinals makes all the sense of the world. Thanks Casey’s for understanding hehehehe I hope to see them in other stores
November 2023
I usually have a good experience here, but when the wrong pizza was delivered they had no solution to make it right. They said they could remake it, but I ordered delivery for a reason and they weren't able to figure out how to have the correct order delivered or refund me the difference between what I ordered and what... read full comment
