Two Dumb Dames offers a delightful selection of treats, including beautiful options like truffles, cake pops, chocolate-covered pretzel sticks, and a variety of fudges. Many customers find the prices a bit high, but the beauty and taste of the products make them worth it. The shop is known for its friendly service and special highlights like the raspberry lemon fudge and dark sea salt caramel fudge, which are made on-site. While the atmosphere is generally welcoming, some visitors have noted that enthusiasm may vary among staff. Overall, the quality of the fudge and saltwater taffy keeps customers returning, even making special trips for their favorite flavors. Online ordering is also available.
One of our must stops when in Eureka , awesome selection, awesome staff. Always fun to pick out rice Krispy treats to take home to everyone, so many flavors to choose from! Good selection of sugar free items, I tried the dark chocolate cherry cordial truffle, omg so good!
June 2026
Can't believe I forgot to review this place. They went the extra mile.
February 2026
Great fudge, I bought 3lbs for my dad's birthday tiger butter, vanilla, dark chocolate sea salt and caramel, peanut butter and maple pecan. My mother's favorite was the vanilla while my dad liked the chocolate and peanut butter. They said all of it was great though.
