Play It Again Sports in Chico is a straightforward business for buying and selling used sports and fitness equipment. It offers a massive selection across many sports, including disc golf, snowboarding, hockey, soccer, and baseball. The disc golf selection is noted as exceptional, being Chico's best by miles with discs at roughly half the cost of new. The quality of the used items is high, with prices described as low to fair, making it seem silly to buy new. However, some new items and even some used equipment can be noticeably more expensive than at other stores. The staff is consistently described as very knowledgeable, friendly, helpful, and non-judgmental, providing excellent service. The store is a fun place to explore with a family. For sellers, they offer payment for used gear, such as fifty cents per pound for weights, with a higher payout if choosing store credit. The overall experience is great, though some note that adjusting pricing on higher-end items could allow for better payouts.
