-
January 2024 by R Debbie Joy
Very disappointed! The place is very dark. Few lights. Got a table quickly by a window. 4:30 so it wasn’t crowded at all. I think just one other table with clients. We ordered the bacon pineapple and the special. Long wait for our pizzas. Terrible crust. So thin it was like a cracker. The toppings were over cooked almost burnt. Gave us no plates to use just 2 napkins and the pizzas on a metal platters. I even commented “No plates?” Nope. Terrible pizza. Had to ask for extra napkins.Don’t waste your time or money.
-
January 2024 by Esmeralda Munoz
The worst pizza ever. We came from.out of town. Walked in. And took long for the food. And costco pizza is even better. . They call that pizza. And get could be cleaner also.
-
December 2023 by Joaquin Estrada
Good place for Reel Genius Trivia and pizza and beer.Definitely worth a visit!
-
November 2023 by May K
a place i can finally eat pizza at! i come here for the pizzas - they are sized just right for one person, with a little bit to take home AND they offer dairy-free cheese. there is always something new on tap at the bar. service is super and a chill place to check out some local art while you're there. Sometimes they have trivia night there tooDietary restrictions: they offer dairy-free cheese as well as gluten-free pizza crust
-
November 2023 by Lei T.
Stopped in for food and beer but it was trivia night so we moved on. Nice crowd and the staff was helpful and welcoming. It wasn't the trivia that madhouse leave, it was the incredible amount of noise bouncing around the hard walls. Some day we'll be back
-
November 2023 by C N
The Madrone has the best tots in the area! They taste fresh, are perfectly crisp and can be enjoyed with a variety of toppings. The Madrone makes their own nacho cheese I highly recommend it. There's also a meat version and a vegetarian version of their sloppy Joe mix. Vegetarians and meat eaters alike can opt for the Sloppy Tots or a Sloppy Dog. Plus they have a nice variety of pizzas, which are more unconventional and small than most places but they're good when you're in the mood for something different. A bit pricey but the people are nice.Vegetarian options: Various lacto-ovo vegetarian options in the pizza menu plus tots with a homemade cheese sauceVegan hot dogs, sloppy joes and cheese available upon request
-
November 2023 by Feral Selector
We eat a lot of gluten free pizza. This one is not very good. It also costs $5 extra, not $1 extra. Pesto also costs extra. We tried it 3 times, this will probably be the last.Vegetarian options: It's pizza, so you choose what you want on itDietary restrictions: Gluten free crust, but it's not very good. Vegan cheese available
-
October 2023 by Richard N.
We loved the pizza. The sauce and crust is what is supposed to be on a pizza and the toppings were a perfect balance. Definitely, a Friday Night date night nominee.
-
October 2023 by Joelyn Smith
Really good good. The sloppy tots are absolutely fire!! And the service is pretty awesome as well!
-
October 2023 by J H
Best pizza I've had in a long time... Definitely going back more
-
August 2023 by Kitty M.
It seems like this is a newer business for Old Town Eureka. They have a large menu and serve pizzas, appetizers, salads, wraps, and some sandwiches. They also have a very nice selection of beers on tap. The restaurant is roomy with space to sure at the bar and about 8 tables. The staff are very nice and friendly.My son ordered the vegan sloppy joes with a side salad and he really enjoyed his meal. It was a good portion, tasty, and filling. My daughter in law ordered the garlic knots and a cheese pizza. The garlic knots were served in a style similar to monkey bread (a pull-a-part style), with loads of chopped garlic and cheese. The cheese pizza was very well done (not done well). The cheese was browned over and had no stretch to it. The crust was thin and wood fired to a cracker crisp. The pizza was so overcooked that we couldn't tell if it had sauce on it. I had a calzone, and it was interesting. The outer crust around the calzone was thick, the skin around the filling of the calzone was really thin, and there was no sauce inside. It wasn't bad tasting, but it wasn't good. It was just ok.All in all our overall experience was a good one because the service was good and the food was okay, but we waited a long time (30 minutes or more) for our order.
-
July 2023 by Robbie Miller
Lunch with Friends
-
July 2023 by Christian Nuñez Alvarez
Went there because of the good reviews and we were interested in the wood fire pizzas. Very disappointed. The pizzaS were dry (overcooked) and not very tasty. We had to wait too long for them too.q1
-
July 2023 by Cody Myers (Keyboard Class)
I came here for a drink and a pizza with my mother who was visiting from Florida. Food was on point like usual, service was excellent, great beer selection. Allowed us to call in our pizza in advance so it was pretty much ready when we got there. There was even a skate event going on that made what already was a great experience, even better.While walking outside of the restaurant, which had quite a few people in the surrounded area because of the event taking place, my 70 year old mother warned me she wasn’t feeling well and completely fainted. She laid their in my arms having a seizure inside of Madrone's event while flocks of people from the event walked past us without saying a word. A passing dog walker unrelated to their event was so concerned (thank you!) helped get my mother water while I rested her head in a comfortable position. This was not alcohol/drug related, but related to being under the 90f sun at the River all day. When we got back in the car she was so apologetic and I told her not to be, but that I was greatly disappointed in Madrone - that during their event, people would just walk by my mother during this health scare. The way this was left, I have no reason to return to or support a business that would allow a patron to lay their passed, convulsing, throwing up, within the confines of their private event and not even have one person so much as ask if we needed water.
-
June 2023 by Lisa
This is literally one of the worst pizzas I have ever had. No exaggeration, Winco pizza from the hot case is better than this. Also the "share sticks" are an absolute joke. They're just a plain pizza crust with a sprinkling of cheese. It's like chewing actual cardboard, only worse. I thought i would try something new, but instead I just got ripped off for 60 bucks. Wish I had read the DoorDash reviews first. Too bad the owner doesn't take an ounce of pride in his business. Save your money and go to Smugs or Paul's.
