-
April 2024 by Sean Faughnan
Needed pizza after the Marathon. Easy to order online. Very friendly when I went to pick up. Greek salad was delicious as was the broccoli. The thin crust was great. No flop. 7.8/10
-
April 2024 by Ross McGregor
We arrived for dinner and it was very busy with a queue out the door. We weren’t expecting to get a table but they managed to fit us in. We were excited to have a good deep dish pizza. We ordered the heritage pizza and a salad to share. As we waited we noticed that a lot of other tables didn’t appear to be eating and before long we realised people were getting a bit fed up. Our salad arrived after around 20 minutes but no sign of the pizza. After around an hour our pizza still hadn’t appeared by which time we’d eaten the salad as we couldn’t wait. We eventually asked what was happening and were told it would be a few minutes. When our pizza arrived, it didn’t appear to have the toppings we were expecting. We queried it and it turned out they had put the Heirloom pizza through the till instead. An easy mistake to make but after an hour of waiting, a pizza with toppings we didn’t really like is not what we wanted. She said the deep dish pizzas take 20 minutes to cook or we could have a thin crust in a few minutes. We opted for the quick one. It was nice when it arrived but the evening was already ruined. We weren’t the only ones either. Such a shame. They did offer us a free drink but didn’t really make up for it.I don’t know if it was a bad night for them but if you can’t keep up with orders, stop taking takeaway orders and stop seating people you can’t feed.
-
April 2024 by Carisse Ballard
The BEST cheesy garlic bread!
-
March 2024 by Jeremiah Hindman
Fantastic pizza and great vibes.
-
March 2024 by Jen Cosmas
Outstanding food, I mean delicious. And the weight stuff is always service oriented and really cares.Dietary restrictions: Great GF pizza. Never know the difference
-
March 2024 by Michael Brown
Very pleasant experience with great pizzaParking: Ample parking close to restaurant
-
March 2024 by Jillian Peterson
Chicago natives thrilled to find legit pizza in Monterey!
-
March 2024 by Ashish Suthar
Best deep dish I can remember having outside of Chicago. Reminded me of Gino’s East. The thin crust was solid too. Forget the locals, cut it in squares! Great service and people.
-
March 2024 by Emily M
Amazing food, very cute atmosphere, and wonderful service! The broccoli was incredible and the spinach salad delicious - the cheese bread was good but I wish it had more garlic. For our smaller pizza there was a miscommunication when we asked for no pineapple and we got double pineapple instead (sadness), but the larger pizza we got was so good and it was a simple misunderstanding. Overall, I would definitely recommend this restaurant and just maybe ask to have the order repeated back to you before they leave to ensure it's how you like it.
-
March 2024 by Shelly Etter
Great pizza and spinach salad delicious too!!
-
February 2024 by Karin Petrites
Hot damn, this pizza is amazingBut the broccoli is really where it's at! And they will make it not spicy if that's your jam. The broccoli has a very close personal relationship with olive oil and doesn't need to explain itself to you.
-
February 2024 by Teresa T
A cozy pizza place that really has a unique spin on pizzas. With deep dish or thin crust options, the ingredients are fresh and flavorful. Our fav is the Heirloom or the Bixby. A small deep dish is ample to share between 2, and we split a salad. It's on our list of must have dinners every time we are in town.Vegetarian options: Can customize a pizza, not all use meat.
-
January 2024 by Nuket Kardam
I love Heirloom Pizza and would go back. The service was excellent. Cozy atmosphere. Delicious thin crust pizza although a little more spicy than I expected. We ordered the butternut squash etc pizza. The Greek salad was very dry and needed some olive oil - generally more dressing.
-
December 2023 by Vivek Nair
Beets were great, served baked instead of cold. Heirloom 9" deep dish was good for 2 reasonably hungry adults. Even though service was warm, they were extremely understaffed for the night.
-
November 2023 by holly sandberg
We ordered appetizer before we even ordered pizza and it all came out together. Very small place, you can't help but hear other conversations going on.
