-
April 2024 by Karen G.
We went there a couple months ago and it was very very slow service. We tried again last night and there weren't many people dining on a Saturday night at 6:00. We were told 10-15 minutes. There weren't any other people waiting in n front of us. After waiting 15 minutes, they asked us if we wanted to go in the bar to eat. We preferred to eat inside the dining area. They said it would be 2 more minutes. They asked another party to go to the bar too who also declined. At least three tables finished eating but they never sat anybody down. After another 15 minutes, we left. We won't be back and if that's normal service, they won't be around much longer.
-
March 2024 by Matt T
Selma's has some of the best pizza in the area and the people are always friendly. The Chicago style pizza is our favorite. Do yourself a favor and eat here.
-
March 2024 by Lindsay A.
This is our go to restaurant and feels like home away from home. The bar is super fun and our favorite bartender, Dillon, knows our order and is the best! Super professional, always willing to chat after a long day's work and make the day better. Food is yummy, beer selection is amazing and the bartenders are top of the line! Highly recommend!! THANKS DILLON!
-
March 2024 by James M.
Inconsistent Quality We ordered the deep dish Pedal To The Metal pizza and it was undercooked. You could still taste the flour and the toppings came out barely cooked. This is very disappointing as this is the third time we ordered from them. The first two came out OK. Since this was ordered for pick-up, it would be too much bother to go back and have them resolve the problem. This makes me hesitant now to order from them again. Update 4/4/2024: Carolina, the general manager got back to me re: experience with my last order. She asked me to give them another chance and sent me a gift card for another pizza. I am definitely going to give it another try as this shows that they are willing to improve their process based on customer feedback. This alone deserves 5 stars as my new rating will show for excellent customer service.
-
March 2024 by Daniela VEGA
The attention is excellentVegetarian options: It has options for all types of dinersParking: It is spacious and very safe
-
March 2024 by Julie C.
Went today with my son and son-in-law Best meal ever Best waiter Food was amazing Machine had a great pizza a great season salad And their spinach dip was amazing .. Didn't come here to watch football.. Great food, great ambience and it was a very nice afternoon ..
-
March 2024 by Scott Brown
Great little pizza joint! Enjoyed the gluten free pizza and my wife loved the thin crust pizza!
-
March 2024 by Susan T.
Spectacular service! I had bought wristbands for the Pliny event for Thursday for my husband. He was so excited to go but he was in Sydney for work. Well, as luck would have it, his flight back was diverted to Hawaii (plane issues, I kid you not) and he was not able to get back until Friday morning (instead of Thursday). He was so upset to miss it and he had also invited a friend along. I gave the restaurant a call and Mike said he'd figure something out, since I'm not a beer drinker. I went that night (with his friend and family) in my husband's stead and sure enough, Mike greeted me and made sure my husband was able to have a sampling of it the next day. He loved it!! The service we received from Mike was over and beyond and I was so grateful that he made my husband's day! Absolutely recommend Selma's and honestly have not see anyone go above and beyond expectations. We will be back for sure!! The food was excellent as welll! (But the service was amazing)
-
March 2024 by Sas Has
I ordered a pizza and it came out burnt and when I asked for it to be fixed one of the blonde girls said it wasn’t possible and so we left disappointed with
-
March 2024 by Lucas Adams
Pretty good pizza at a so-so price point. My party ordered 4 pizzas and I liked the carnivore/meat lovers the best.
-
February 2024 by Chris F
Wonderful food and great drinks. Great service except for one thing.The last three times I've been here, I've tried to get an Artisan pizza with just Pepperoni. I've even specifically said "No mushrooms, please" and had the server acknowledge that. And the last three times I've tried, somebody along the way doesn't get the "No mushrooms" memo and they put mushrooms on the pizza.If I had a nickel every time this team has ignored my request for no mushrooms, I'd have three nickels, which isn't a lot but it's weird that it's happened this consistently. PLEASE do better.
-
February 2024 by Joseph McGriff
Delicious pizza, salads and beers with great service in a fun setting. Don't forget the mother ship!
-
February 2024 by Gary S.
I was trying to introduce my girlfriends son to Chicago style thick crust pizza. We arrived at the store for lunch and were greeted by a server. We were seated and served quickly. We got two small pizza's, one thick crust and one thin. One was Da Vinny and the other was the Meathead. Both were delicious. The thin crust had a crispy crust - we asked for it to be extra crispy. There were plenty of toppings and overall it was delicious. The same applies for the thick crust pizza. The only criticism I have for the thick crust was that it too was extra crispy, I think it should have been a little less crispy. Overall, a great experience at Selma's.
-
February 2024 by Mike Ellerman
Good Italian/pizza. Had the lasagna which I wish had more pasta inside. Maybe should have ordered the baked ziti instead. Both Caesar and Greek salads are amazing and the small is definitely not small.
-
February 2024 by Gwenevere C.
One of our favorites. We love their garlic cheese bread, salads, pizzas, and even their pastas. Probably everything else too but we have not tried it all. And their ranch dress...it's the best!!
