-
March 2024 by Richard Newman
Sadly, it's just not good anymore under the new ownership. You know that saying about things that ain't broke. Well, they tried to fix something and the results are sadly underwhelming, to say the least. Sad to see a Fort Collins institution go to waste.Edit: if you have that much time and effort to respond to an honest review, you're failing your guests and employees by serving subpar food. JRR Tolken taking over Pickle Barrel isn't what I expected. But his works were worth reading.
-
March 2024 by Amy Arnott
We have been getting Pickle Barrel sandwiches since the early 1990s. We used to love their sandwiches! Today, we ordered for delivery our usual toonces sandwich. It was horrible, super salty, bread was over toasted and not grilled. Sadly I will never go back, it had been going downhill, but it just hit rock bottom.
-
March 2024 by Dave Rumsey
Great Cuban sandwich with friendly service.
-
March 2024 by Nicholus Baker
I used to love this place. Since new ownership took over, the portion sizes are smaller, the prices are higher and the quality is inferior overall. We were even sitting st the bar and the bartender rang us up and gave our check without us even asking for it or stating that we were finished. Would not recommend.
-
February 2024 by Leah Kerrigan
A true Fort Collins gem! My husband and I come here every time that we are in town. The sandwiches are sooo good.
-
January 2024 by Michael M.
The food is alright. It's nothing to scream over. But closing at 4PM on a Saturday is; considering how much they charge through services like Nosh etc. rude business practice. They gouge the hell out of you having to order through third party systems If you want delivery; and they love being this way. There's no weekend schedule that works feasibly. The residence of FoCo should be catered to as well not just pandering to the college. Because mediocre food is just what I need sometimes but on reflection it's a good thing. No one should be charged so much and being forced to use third party systems is just a business tactic to earn more money. $28 for one sandwich and a side? Are you joking? From a fast food place.... It's not artisanal in any manner. I work in an actual small business. We stay open past closing hours just to ensure the satisfaction of customers coming in. In fact, if customers are still coming we DO NOT close. Bc... you know... money? That thing. Never close until you sell out of product on a normal business day. We are open on Saturdays so I certainly can make a comparison.
-
January 2024 by BJ Lopez
I've been going to PB since the mid 90's. Always great food and great place to hang. Smoked pastrami was delish! The new back area is nice.I like to fill my belly at the pickle barrel deli.
-
January 2024 by N8
Delicious sandwiches!
-
January 2024 by Jodi Holthouser
The new wheat bread is
-
January 2024 by Dane Parker
Great spot for a soup and sandwich. The staff is wonderful and their draft selection is solid.
-
January 2024 by Hoovy McBoovy
I think a small, squished, 6 inch sized sandwich for $12.95 is kinda crazy. Its not even filled with much. And thats a full sandwich according to the menu.I decided to give pickle barrel another try, but this happened again and I can't say I feel inclined to come back for a third.
-
January 2024 by Jaxson Dugger
Awesome sandwich stop , great Reuben +
-
January 2024 by Todd Leven
Great and unique sandwiches!
-
January 2024 by Russ Pierce
They have some really distinctive and unique sandwiches here. Give them a try.
-
December 2023 by Ava Diamond
I have never had a Reuben sandwich. A friend of mine told me that theirs were good, so I decided to go there and try one. It was also my first visit to Pickle Barrel.The bartender took my order, and was very nice and friendly. My sandwich came out quickly.At first, I was wondering if they even put any sauerkraut on it, because I couldn’t taste it. I opened the sandwich, and one half didn’t seem to have any, and the other half had very little.I grew up in New York and I’m used to both corned beef and pastrami being super tender. This meat was rather chewy.All in all, I was pretty unimpressed. I don’t think I will go back there.The spicy pickle was really good, though.
