Remember When Baseball Cards is a friendly and welcoming store that offers a good mix of vintage and modern cards. Customers appreciate the fair prices, especially on the dollar bins and pack selections, and find the staff knowledgeable and gentle when handling cards. The store features a variety of products, including wax, boxes, supplies, and vintage cards, making it suitable for collectors of all budgets. The owners are passionate and go above and beyond to explain the industry and assist customers, creating a rewarding experience. Many reviewers mention their positive experiences, discounts, and the pleasure of opening mystery boxes. The store maintains a clean environment and is committed to giving back to the community. Overall, Remember When Baseball Cards provides a great collecting environment with good prices, friendly service, and a well-updated inventory, making it a popular spot for both new and seasoned collectors.
Great experience! Sold a cpl cards and got a nice Walt Frazier. Will be back.
February 2026
Great place to do business..totally forgot his name..but gave me tip and facts on a few things..i believe it's was joe ..good guy
December 2025
I get doubles many times in the 500 box the$ I've spent there it's now$28 use to be be$20 and no doubles I've got about 75 doubles throughout the last 5 years of like 6 boxes I've bought
