Big Y in Middletown is a clean, well-stocked grocery store that offers a variety of fresh and quality products. Customers appreciate the convenient location with easy in-and-out access, including a side entrance with Grab & Go options like sushi, pizza slices, fruit, soup, deli, and bakery items. The store features a bakery, a produce section, and a meat department, making it a one-stop shop. Many reviews highlight the friendly staff and the store’s open, breezy setup, which enhances the shopping experience. The store provides good prices, especially with regular discounts and the myBigY Rewards program, helping customers save money. While some find the prices slightly higher, the quality of food and the variety of options, including freshly made sushi and party-sized pizzas, make it worthwhile. A few comments mention issues with music volume and staff attitude, but overall, Big Y Middletown is seen as a reliable, pleasant grocery destination for the community.
We love Big Y and recently had an exceptional experience with Lori- she was able to accommodate a last minute Sub shop request with such kindness and professionalism. The sandwiches were wonderful and we were so impressed by her hard work!
February 2026
Love the store and staff . The deli staff is amazing. Fresh .
December 2025
My husband brought home the best croissants and you sell them individually. Out of this world. Keep offering them individually. Don't change your recipe.i just finished mine. I could eat them every day. Just heat and eat.
