The Wine Thief is a highly regarded liquor store known for its amazing selection and friendly, helpful staff. Customers appreciate the team's assistance in finding the perfect bottle to complement meals or for gifts. The knowledgeable staff consistently provide excellent recommendations for sparkling wines, gins, and tequilas. Visitors feel welcomed and enjoy the great suggestions, making it worth the extra time to visit. With fair prices and an extensive selection, The Wine Thief stands out as the best liquor store in New Haven.
If you are a wine aficionado, this is THE spot. Crazy selection. Pierre peters at $88!? Lots of Von winning and Italian whites. Epic selection. Took 4 bottles home and ended up drinking all of them in the same night.
July 2025
Love how the team at Wine Thief assists the customers rather than standing behind the counter. Great experience and selection!
March 2025
Amazing selection and helpful staff to find just the bottle you’re wishing you knew how to find yourself to complement your meal
