Pennywise Consignment Shop is a family-owned and operated business that has been providing designer consignment clothing, shoes, and purses for women and men since 1988. The shop offers a diverse selection of brand-name and factory overstock items, with a constantly changing inventory to keep customers coming back. Pennywise is known for its reasonable prices, on-trend styles, and exceptional customer service. Reviewers praise the store's cleanliness, organization, and friendly staff, who are always willing to help customers find what they're looking for. The shop features a two-floor layout with thousands of consignors, ensuring a wide variety of options for shoppers. One of the unique aspects of Pennywise is its color-coded markdown system, similar to Goodwill, which allows customers to take advantage of regular sales and discounts. The shop has also hosted successful warehouse sales, where everything was priced under $20, providing an opportunity for customers to build their wardrobes on a budget. Overall, Pennywise Consignment Shop is a beloved local business that has earned a reputation for its high-quality merchandise, fair prices, and excellent customer service. Whether you're looking for a designer bargain or simply browsing for a unique find, Pennywise is a must-visit destination in the Mystic, Connecticut area.
Awesome Consignment Shop! One of the best I've been to!
May 2026
Stumbled across this place as we were passing through and really loved the vibe, staff were super friendly and I managed to find a pair of jeans that were super cute and fit me perfectly (which is so tough for a plus size gal these days)
May 2026
This is a very impressive consignment shop. Their inventory is terrific. I can't wait to go back. The staff is very friendly & kind.
