-
December 2023 by David R.
Seems like my older review has been reviewed. If you want to see what a bad customer service manager is like just read the replies on here from Manager O. This place was so much better in past lives.
-
October 2023 by Linda Taylor
Crabs was bolied and unseasoned. chicken was burnt,The best part was the corn, hush puppies and cola soda.I will never revist this place again.I like my crabs steamed not boiled.That's the Maryland way of fixing steam crabs.
-
October 2023 by Jason B.
Crabs were under legal size about 4 inches, cold and had an ammonia smell, server was a disgrace, very rude, no refills. Greeters seemed annoyed that me and my wife came in, bathroom disgusting. Server tossed the check onto the table and ignored our complaints and made it seem like it was our fault the crabs sucked. Never coming back I love how professional the manager responded to my problems
-
October 2023 by Robert Burrell
I will be going back soon. Food atmosphere all good. Prices also good. I wished I lived closer.If anyone is thinking about going, don't think too hard Just Go you will be Happy You
-
October 2023 by Eric Cathell
Always a great place to eat. Ayce crabs were awesome. They'd just lost most of their college crew in back to school, so service was a bit slower than normal.
-
October 2023 by Alex Jackson
I went with a group Sunday night, and the food was great. It was the first time my son had been there and he loved it. It was busy but very nice and pleasant. I had the snow crab legs bucket, and it was more than enough. For great seafood, I recommend it.
-
October 2023 by Mollie Kaufman
This place is always wonderful, the crabs just keep coming and they are delicious. I also loveeeeee the hush puppies. The only thing that bothers me is the fact that I pay $80 and can't bring anything home. I understand the crab part, but what about the things I didn't ask for refills on, such as the chicken, clam strips and shrimp. Those are already included in the price that I paid, and if I didn't ask for refills on any of those I should be able to take it home with me instead of them throwing it in the trash as soon as I leave. If anything they should at least donate that food to homeless people. Such a waste of food and it breaks my heart. Especially with how much people are struggling in today's economy. Just my thoughts and hopefully the owners have a change of heart.But other than that this place is great!! Highly recommend!
-
October 2023 by SpcT0rres
Great little all you can eat crabs. We go here every year.
-
October 2023 by Kristin Davis
The food is good but the staff needs MAJOR work. The two waitresses that were serving us were rude, had nasty attitudes, did not sing happy birthday to my 14 year old brother because she was “shy” meanwhile other tables were being celebrated and acted entitled. One waitress had cut me off while speaking to her multiple times, rolled her eyes, pointed her fingers at me, then made it seem like we were stealing food because SHE delivered two extra crab legs to our table… I’ve never when to a restaurant with worst attitudes. Had a somewhat similar experience last year when we visited but it was brushed off. They were lucky that we drove over 2 hours away to the restaurant… I don’t know them and they obviously do not know me….
-
September 2023 by TaskIt T.
Food was ok. Crab Mac and cheese was really good. Hush puppies delicious. Snow crabs were overcooked And they don't have the right tools to crack snow crabs so a few claws were impossible to crack with the cheap tools they do have. That was very disappointing.
-
September 2023 by Tiffany C.
There's only one word to describe Old Mill Crab House and that's; Superb!!! As soon as you enter there's a hospitable burst of energy and a setup that makes you immediately feel as if you are about to feast on the worlds best crabs. I opted for the All you can eat blue crabs and let me tell you; they were the best blue crabs I've ever eaten. Seasoned to perfection. The portions served are definitely not for one person however, you are not permitted to share the All you can eat options. I also enjoyed the hush puppies with confectioners sugar, the corn was scrumptious and the fried chicken had a soulful kick. The service is prompt and our waitress was extremely attentive and made me and my mom feel right at home.
-
September 2023 by J M.
For a traditional seafood meal and crabs this is the best I have found in the area. Took my dad and he was back in his youth cracking crabs until he had trouble getting up. Highly recommended. Not much if anything for vegetarians.
-
September 2023 by Lauren M.
We came here for a family birthday party. They do not take reservations and all members of the party must be there before you're seated. I was worried at first we would have a long wait because there were 19 of us, however this allowed us to be seated in only 10 mins on a Saturday afternoon. Our food came out within 20 minutes and my shrimp feast was wonderful (except the corn, it wasn't that good). Loved the hush puppies with the powdered sugar and the shrimp. Fried chicken wasn't great, just average. All in all I would go back if we didn't live over 2 hours away.
-
August 2023 by Gina
Took my mom here for the first time drove 3hrs food was good!My only complaint they have to find a better way for the disposal of food the the trash can in the aisles makes it hard to walk thru especially when u need canes, crutches, and walkers for support
-
August 2023 by l little
I was told it's a hit or miss with the blue crabs...Food and service were good. Crabs not as meaty as I would have like but overall great place. I would definitely go back. They were good about bring more food when asked. Our waitress was very attentive and personable so made it an enjoyable experience.**One issue is fried foodwas overcooked this time.