-
April 2024 by Alexis Zuber
Tonight my boyfriend and I went to Cafe Gelato for dinner. I had made a reservation for 7 pm. When we arrived at 6:50 we were not greeted by any staff member. It was busy, we could tell and we were okay… at first. At 7:15 we were finally sat. At 7:30 no one had come to greet us or ask for our drink order, so we decided to ask the hostess what was happening. When our server came by I noticed that he was serving the table next to us and came by at least 5 times in those 15 minutes and not ONCE checked on us. When he finally arrived at our table he didn’t even apologize for the wait. The entire 45 minutes we were there we felt completely invisible to all staff working. We decided to leave without eating dinner. We are not ones to make a huge fuss out of things, but we are incredibly disappointed with the service we received tonight. We happily took our business elsewhere.
-
April 2024 by Matt
In an area where everything is so new its sterilized it feels good to walk into this place. Food is great, staff is great, service is awesome. What else is there?
-
April 2024 by Iskeisha Stuckey
Great date night!
-
April 2024 by Isabella W
Beautifully renovated dining room, great food choices with some vegetarian and gluten free options. Extensive wine list. Probably the classiest place in Newark!
-
March 2024 by Michael Lundin
Love this placeFood was amazingChill atmosphere - can get busy and crowded at times, space is a little tight but worth it - been here several times and loved it every
-
March 2024 by Darcel Earl
Everything was great!
-
March 2024 by Dottie Beene
This is our favorite place to celebrate together. It's always special. The food is exquisite and so is the wonderful service.
-
March 2024 by Rachel Kane
Cafe Gelato has catered 2 events for us this past year where our families, staff, and board members had an amazingly good experience. The food was fantastic and the service was great. In addition, Cafe Gelato supports our mission to enable and inspire the youth throughout our State.
-
March 2024 by Frank Garahan
I will never return to this restaurant because I got a $70 parking ticket bc of slow service
-
March 2024 by allen1441AO
Above average/good food. Amazing service. Cool atmosphere.
-
March 2024 by Jamie Mack
Fabulous night out for our daughter's birthday. Wonderful atmosphere, staff were friendly, knowledgeable on the wine list and they were attentive without ever feeling rushed. The burrata fritta was excellent as were the pastas dishes at the table. Filet mignon was phenomenal, with the mashed potatoes spiked with smoked mozzarella and the veal demi Glace. Definitely somewhere we'll visit again.
-
March 2024 by Lisa M. Foti
Excellent service ? ? and delicious food! Awesome spot for a birthday celebration ?
-
March 2024 by Kelly G-D
Recommend calling ahead for a table. Week nights can get crowded with local business parties.
-
March 2024 by Karen Andrea
There were too many people crammed into the space. Consequently, the noise level was so loud that you could hardly hear the music.
-
March 2024 by Naani Dang
I have been calling with questions, about setting up a large birthday dinner for my friends! An employee named Kyle has been very patient and knowledgeable, when answering my questions and providing me with info. I was able to reserve a private room today and discuss menu options for our party. I am super excited to dine in!
