-
April 2024 by Warren Post
Excellent fresh seafood.
-
April 2024 by Jeffrey Wright
We have two boys ages 4 and 6 years so dining out isn’t an option. We stop in to Capt Anthony’s each day for fresh catch seafood and the best Ceviche on the island. Special thanks to the owner on the cooking advice and aluminum grill pan. Fish turns out perfect every time! We also got the fresh shrimp and it was outstanding.
-
March 2024 by John Hynes
Long time customer...usually 12 + bls of crab claws @ a time !For offshore fishing they're ....perfect!Crackem on the transom and off to the races !!Love Joanne and Capt.Ant..I WILL BESTOPPING BYVERY SOON!!!
-
January 2024 by Oliver Smagacz
Great sushi and very nice people
-
January 2024 by Amanda Roe
Delicious! Great fish dip! Great sushi! Good people!
-
January 2024 by Ashley Smagacz
Amazing sushi and customer service!!
-
December 2023 by Renee W.
The Best & freshest seafood ever , my husband and I also stayed in there rental cottage which was so pretty & perfect just steps from the beach . Between the fantastic seafood and their beautiful cottage I didn't wanna leave !!! Thank you JoAnn & Capt Anthony
-
December 2023 by David Rinkenberger
Love going to Captain Anthony’s every time we are on AMI. The freshest grouper and crab claws you can find. A true gem you must not miss!
-
November 2023 by hannah Bostard
Had such an amazing experience! The women working was so pleasant & so nice! She even opened up for us after hours which was unbelievably sweet! Everything is so Fresh, highly recommend!
-
October 2023 by David F.
Ordered some grouper to broil at the house. Very fresh and very tasty. Staff very friendly and helpful. Not muck to look at but definitely worth the visit.
-
September 2023 by Dylan Harrison
Purchased fresh red grouper and red snapper from Captain Anthony. Best I’ve ever had! Owners were great and very informative. Highly recommend!
-
September 2023 by Paul Vahanian
We stopped when they happened to be closed wondering if we should come by the next day and we were very aggressively and very rudely verbally aggressed by drunken owners. Not okay.
-
September 2023 by David Idell
Capt Anthony’s has amazing fresh seafood, the best in the area!! Go see Capt Anthony and Joann, awesome people who are passionate about their community, fishing and seafood!!
-
July 2023 by Casey Kaercher
Joanne is THE BEST! We had the best stone crab claws with delicious mustard sauce on the beach. My 83 year old dad said it was better than winning the lottery! Great family experience!
-
May 2023 by Kristy Hust
Homemade octopus ceviche!! We visited Captain Anthony's twice during our stay on AMI. Day One we got the smoked king fish dip and it was AMAZING. They also offered smoked grouper dip and grouper ceviche which we happily got as well. The ceviche was so flavorful! Lemony, with a little heat from the fresh peppers and a ton of cilantro! Lots of veggies! Day 2 we went back and got some fresh grouper filets to grill for our dinner, along with some freshly prepared octopus ceviche. What a FEAST! We met Joanne and her husband, Captain Anthony, two very nice AMI residents who've lived on island and raised their family there. Anthony's a local Florida native and had some great history on how his family arrived to the island. Joanne is so much fun to chat with, she even let us sample some of the prepared octopus before the ceviche was ready! Highly recommend getting your seafood fix at Captain Anthony's, you'll love this little place!
