-
April 2024 by Nancy M.
Pizza crust was burned and sauce seemed like just regular tomato sauce with no spices or seasoning. Previous owners pizza was much better. April 24
-
April 2024 by The Captain
Pine Island Pizza is serving to a captive audience. It doesn't have to be very good because it's the only pizza place for miles around. Service was good but pizzas over all we're mediocre at best. Honestly I've had better pizzas from Domino's. It is what it is if your stuck on the island wanting pizza unless you grab a couple frozen pies from publix...that would probably be better, and cheaper..
-
April 2024 by Karli Drake
We stayed with my wife's Gramma on pine Island and went to this pizza shop. It was delectable! Absolutely delicious, best pizza we've ever had! Definitely, 10/10 recommend!
-
March 2024 by Ben Dover
Excellent pepperoni (slice ask for well done) amazing pizza top 3 in Lee county
-
March 2024 by Vladimir Costa
This is the best pizza in town.
-
March 2024 by TravelUSA
Ordered Large with everything on it. Pizza was ready when I arrived in 15 mins as promised!One of the best pies I have had in awhile ?.Both team members I interacted with were very friendly and genuinely appreciated my business! Kudos to the owner, manager and the motivated staff. It's refreshing to experience this level of service. ?Parking: Parking in rear parking lot is best, there are a few parking spots in front of shop.
-
March 2024 by Pat Hansbury
Called for a large cheese pizza to pick up. First time there. Good pizza. Good taste, crunchy crust. Reasonable price.
-
March 2024 by Mindy Hines
Huge slices. Very yummy. Had pizza, wings, and the cheesy garlic knots. All were fantastic. Highly recommend.
-
March 2024 by michael frank
you can get the same pizza in any gas station for less than half the price. the cheesesteak was absolutely the worst i have ever had, the roll was toasted like a crouton, the meat which was scarse was full of griscle and knots, will never visit
-
March 2024 by Jennifer Yelvington
The meatball appetizer was delicious along with the pizza. The cannoli was an added bonus. Service was also top notch. Will definitely take the drive back out there
-
March 2024 by Alexandria Tallant
The pizza and garlic knots were delicious! We will be coming back soon to try more items on the menu.
-
February 2024 by E. M.
We really love the pizza here and since we live in a near location, it is our go to pizza place. We order on line. It is a fabulous system as you can pick everything you want and even go w half pizza mushrooms and other half sausage, etc and it has what most places don't. It's NOT greasy, slimy, over salted, cheap cheese stuff! It's crisp great crust, perfect baked w all the trimmings you could want. I like the hamburger, extra tomatoes and mushrooms the best. My fella likes sausage, onions and green peppers. It's on time and smooth to order as their online ordering is really easy and problem free. This is our takeout place but you may also eat there.
-
February 2024 by Drew Gardner
Some of the best pizza around. Good crust, good sauce, just a good pie. I like mine well done. The lunch special is a decent price too.
-
February 2024 by bop blop
Staff struggles to correctly bake pies, I've ordered over 10 times, theres a number of factors at play:1. Sauce retains too much liquid, this prevents the center of the pie from reaching the desired temp before the crust burns. The extra water content also reduces the flavor leading to a lackluster zest.2.Dough is thin but raw, probably due to being wet, reference #1. Your pizza falls apart and cannot maintain structure to any degree.3. There is too much cheese for how undercooked the pies are, I love hefty cheese but you need a correctly baked pie with structure. As is the cheese just slides off the top of the pizza completely leaving a garbage pile of watery mess.4. Only one chef is good at their job and its not the large guy. Retrain your staff, the only respectable chef is the slightly older moderate build guy. Even the competent chef struggles due to 1/2/3.I reccomend you recalibrate your oven and baking process, bring in a pro or experiment yourself. You have a great business but your food quality and staff training are holding you back
-
February 2024 by MICHELLE SAMBRATO
Oh my goodness. This is now my new favorite pizza in town! We had 5 adults and 8 kids and the service was fast and friendly but the Pizza's and Stromboli we ordered was fantastic. I highly recommend you check this place out. We will definitely be back!! It was soooooo good!