-
March 2024 by Bradley Schlichting
Well I went somewhere else tonight because even though I called around 915pm to place an order with Time Square pizza and they didn't close until 10pm according to the website I was greeted with a we are closed... Click. Try the place east over the bridge just on the left in the plaza. They have really good pizza.
-
March 2024 by JoJo F
I just love the texture and flavor of their pizza, so delicious and everyone is working getting the orders
-
February 2024 by P K.
Received the wrong item. I was told they would make it up to me. well they didn't. item went in the trash. Don't go they are not nice when they make an error.
-
February 2024 by Simone Pex
Alright. Let's get into it. This pizza ? is absolutely ??? seriously Chefs kiss the crust is perfection, doesn't get soggy in the middle, the sauce is light and has the perfect tang (acidity) the cheese has a nice pull, quality mozzarella, the eggplant topping is crispy and delicious full of flavor and their sausage shaved and so good. This was literally the perfect New York Pizza. Workers were kind, now the reason this got 4 Stars is because the place is fkn filthy lol the walls and the air vents oh dear lord, I'm laughing because I can't believe how bad it is, man they need a serious scrubbing. Just take it to go, this is not an eat in place. The owner should seriously consider investing a little bit into sprucing the place up a bit besides that, it was magnificent. Will definitely return.
-
February 2024 by Kori Swanson
I felt like I was really eating a New York Pizza it was so delicious and the staff was very nice and very considerate I had a wonderful dinner.
-
February 2024 by Joseph S.
I used this visit NYC all the time for several years for work. This place is like the best NYC pie you could find. This is a compliment. Great sauce. Not floppy (I ask them to leave it in a little longer) and great sauce to cheese ratio. Anyways. The pie is bomb. Haven't had anything else.
-
February 2024 by Noah W.
This place is very good. Some of the best pizza and sub I've had that I can remember. I had a pepperoni and jalapeño pizza and a meatball sub. Both were phenomenal. I will 100% be back
-
February 2024 by Ping
Special lunch set for 8$1 drink , 1 salad and 1 pizza ? very good pizza ?I just order Cannoli to try is good also excellent
-
February 2024 by Downrange Film
They charge customers for using credit cards now. Place is dirty
-
January 2024 by F. Nicholas Ciacelli cia
Very negative to ask people to if you want to pay cash or credit I'm not worth $0.75 if I pay my credit card for a $10 order? The food is great the people are good but many are overlooking. Bathrooms are in horrible shape interior of the restaurant is dirty and old and needs updating. It appears that hasn't been touched since they opened. Ceilings the walls everything needs a good scrubbing and a good refurbish. I won't go there again because of the fact that they charge a different price for cash. Or credit. I ordered a meatball sub and a drink and they want to know if I wanted to pay cash or credit so I paid by cash saving them only 74 cents. That's a really stupid decision by whoever owns the place. I've been coming there for 40 years but I'll never go there again. Are things really that bad that you have to do that? Owners like this don't invest a dime in the floors the ceilings the walls the core of the bathrooms but they'll charge you $74 more if you use a credit card give me a break?
-
January 2024 by Russell F.
Calling yourself Times Square Pizza is a bit ballsy when you're nowhere near New York. But, this pizzeria got its name from the little shopping center it's located in, not Manhattan. Walking into TSP, it had the right smell and feel as a NY pizzeria. It was a busy night with 2 guys making pizza's exclusively, TSP makes 18" pizzas, which is the size of any reputable real NY pizzeria. They stretched the dough out by hand, but there was no tossing of the dough. I ordered an 18" pie, half meatball and a slice of Sicilian with anchovy. The pie was overly cheesy. The sauce was excellent & robust. The crust had an ok bite and chew, but was very airy and lacked flavor. The meatballs on top were plentiful and tasty. The Sicilian slice was huge, but not the right type of dough; it wasn't dense enough. Again, it was too airy and lacked flavor. Overall, the pizza was better than most in South Florida, but it just didn't quite reach that level of pizza excellence I look for.
-
January 2024 by Marion Starks
You can’t go wrong with this pizza! Best in town!
-
January 2024 by Blas Bonilla
Finding a good slice of pizza in Florida can be challenging for a Native New Yorker. Fortunately, I walked by this spot and gave it a shot because of the aroma of a good pizza being baked. After shooting the breeze with staff, I ordered a pie with extra cheese, extra sauce, and well done. "Fuhgeddaboudit!" I wasn't let down, which was a win for me! I haven't tried anything else on the menu, but I'm hoping that when I do, Times Square Pizza will knock it out of the park, too!
-
January 2024 by Michael Fuller
Good spot for a slice when you're in a pinch.Pizza Adventures: Destination #204
-
January 2024 by Martin Swartz
Solid NY style pizza. We ordered delivery and it came early. Will order again.
