Gifts & More at The Paper Store offers a unique shopping experience with a variety of Florida-themed gifts, delicious fruit, and quality products. The business features a post office and is known for shipping fresh fruit, including highly praised oranges and grapefruits. Customers appreciate the excellent quality of the orange lip balm and the delightful orange-flavored soft serve ice cream. Many reviews highlight the exceptional taste of the orange and grapefruit juices, though some note recent changes in pricing and product availability. Despite being a bit pricey, the juices are regarded as superior to grocery store options. The store is a popular destination for both locals and tourists, boasting ample parking, indoor and outdoor seating, and a children's play area. Reviewers commend the pleasant and engaging staff, who go above and beyond to create memorable customer experiences. From helping customers create custom gift baskets to offering samples and sharing stories about the products, the team’s dedication to service is frequently noted. Overall, Gifts & More at The Paper Store is a charming location that merges quality products with a personal touch, making it a must-visit in the Fort Myers area.
Post office inside. Nice place to order shipped fruit. Has oranges to buy along with many florida themed gifts, jams hot sauces and candy. Also soft serve ice-cream.
December 2025
I ordered the orange lip balm and the quality was excellent. Also has a nice orange fragrance. I am looking forward to my oranges and grapefruit coming in January. I also have sampled the orange and grapefruit juice and both were excellent.
December 2025
We had white grapefruit delivered out of state. They are the best we’ve ever had. Highly recommended and worth every cent.
