Jewelry Stores in Islamorada, FL

“I’ve called multiple jeweler's about this ring and never got a reply or response. Have sent emails with no replies. All along had been sitting on the Blue Marlin website. Couldn’t see a size on it so I called BM and phone was answered within 2 rings by a very happy employee, Nancy. Nancy was kind, courteous and very helpful. She got everything moving and with 90 minutes purchase was made. Text messages from Ramsey and purchase complete.Will be going to Blue Marlin Jewelry for future purchases.”

“Island Time Gutters are a great local business. They do what is promised at the price they quoted and quickly too! With all the local “sharks” here- you are in safe waters with Omar and his team. :)”

“What a little hidden gem of a spot! My friends who own a place in the middle Keys recommended this area to stop for some cool shopping and coffee. At first we actually passed the parking lot...I'd be surprised if other people did as well! The Village Square entrance is a bit set in through a gate in a fence...very inconspicuous if you don't know it's there. So we made a u-turn and headed back...My first stop was the Miss Monroe Boutique as I was looking for a certain kind of bag that I wanted to buy. Very cute store - like a mix of Etsy and Lily Pulitzer...unique and distinct items. From there we walked around and checked out all the cool vendor stalls...My favorite was the plants - so beautiful and lush...macrame holders, etc....We also went to Cafe Moka for a coffee and a snack. We sat down in the garden to enjoy our small meal and then we headed on our way...We will definitely stop here again!”

“I went in to get some accessories and ended up taking two divine sponge soaps. It's a shame that they don't have social networks or more information about the products, which I think makes it a bit mystical and special. Whenever I come back I will visit them to take something with me. Everything is truly divine and the attention is spectacular ??✨?”

“Thanks so much to the artist and owners for repairing a electrical problem in one of our beautiful lamps that we have in our master bedroom that we bought years ago . Replaced parts right on the spot and insisted not to charge me for anything. They keep making new artistic pieces all the time andgreat place to look for art pieces for home or gifts. Will be back and bring friends back too.”

“Kathy is so sweet! We are tourists here and stopped in on a whim. The store is immaculate, and so fresh smelling. She provided a visitors map and highlighted al the places that are “worth visiting”. Beautiful shop.”

“The service at both the Islamorada and Ocean Reef locations is phenomenal. I am sure it is in Nantucket too - will have to test it out soon! I appreciate the variety of styles and continuous turn over of inventory - which is a challenge on a island. Thank you for keeping us beautiful locally!”

“I have friends that live in Marathon so I am in the Keys several times a year. We rarely go farther than a 3 mile radius.....except for fishing! This last trip it was windy so we actually drove up and down the Keys multiple times being tourists. I stopped in my favorite bookstore in Islamorada to purchase another copy of Capt Fizz's book on Treasure Salving to re-read. When we got home, I started looking up some coin information online. I have a 1 Reale pendant that I love for the shape and I started thinking about maybe getting an (authentic) 8 Reale for my husband for his upcoming birthday. After quite a bit of looking, I kept coming back to one listed by DePaula Jewelers. Not so coincidentally it was a Capt. Fizz coin! I kicked myself for not getting this idea while I was THERE and could have shopped in person. I sent an email with a couple of questions and got a response the next day. My questions were answered and I was offered an incentive to purchase. SOLD! I PayPal'd the money and my purchase was mailed immediately. Thankfully the husband went offshore fishing today so *I* got the mail. O_O. The only drawback is that now I have to wait to give the gift! It is SO cool. I feel like I got 5 star service even with an online purchase. And I like that I got to shop from my home away from home. I recommend this store for unique items and superb service.”

“I met Natacha just browsing the shops and when I went in I was memorized! All handmade, real quality and a variety for all u need for a vacation, last min items to gorgeous souvenirs! She offers hair braiding, I had 2 done, just perfect, ,I feel so pretty! After I had 2, I went back for 2 more braids the next day. Prices are so fair and other than the braids I also purchased a handmade rope bracelet for my son and a couple crocheted sea creatures, the octopus is so adorable! I've never been so enthralled with a gift shop! Highly recommend!”