Sugar Shark Market
Grocery Stores
Hours:
3124 Overseas Highway, Key West FL 33040
Hours
About Sugar Shark Market
Sugar Shark Market is a local shop in the middle Keys. It is a great grocery stop for anyone living or visiting the area. The market has everything you could want: grocery items, a meat selection, prepped sandwiches, meal prep kits, skincare staples, clothes, vintage home goods, home decor, and gift items. It also sells locally churned ice cream, packaged beer, and refreshing drinks. The store is well kept and offers great service. It has an array of goods that keeps you from driving any kind of distance. It is a surprisingly nice small grocery and bodega-style market with quality food items, drinks, snacks, and merchandise. The must-try item is the Not Fried Chicken Ice Cream, which looks like a fried chicken drumstick but is really a pretzel stick dipped in chocolate, wrapped in vanilla ice cream, dipped again, and coated in cornflakes. It is clever, funny, and really good. The market also has an amazing collection of unique souvenirs and cute merch. It has so much charm, and a lot of care goes into everything they offer. It is the best store in the Keys and 100% worth stopping by.
Most Recent Reviews
-
June 2026
Great local shop with an array of goods that keeps you from driving any kind of distance. Well kept and great service. From steaks to ice cream and all in between it’s a great local find!
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
-
June 2026
The guy chip is super nice and chill love to have conversations with him
-
May 2026
Very cute little store. You will find everything there. ALL the stuff is healthy choices. And ice-cream so good.
More Comments(36)
You May Also Like
-
Key West, Florida