Amici Family Bakery is a popular local spot known for its delicious baked goods. Many customers have praised the bakery's signature cannolis, often making special trips to enjoy this treat. The bakery also offers catering options with large trays of cookies and cannolis. Service is noted to be attentive and friendly. However, there have been recent concerns about inconsistencies in the quality of some items, such as the sandwich cookies, black and whites, and linzer cookies. Some customers have reported issues with the filling of the linzer cookies and the quality of the previously raspberry jam, now replaced with a thinned-out jelly. There have been observations that some cookies, like the rainbow cookies, seem to be purchased instead of baked in-house. Additionally, portions have been noted to be smaller. Despite these concerns, Amici Family Bakery has loyal customers who have had positive experiences with the bakery, especially with their cannolis. Customers have praised the amazing selection, with the pignoli cookies and carrot cake being personal favorites. The Pastry Chef, Michelle, is highly skilled and has received praise for her expertise. Customers hope for a return to the bakery's previous quality standards and an end to credit card usage fees.
Fantastic Italian desserts. Our first experience with Amici’s bakery was when Michelle provided the desserts for a work party. Now we’re pretty much weekly customers. Cookies, cupcakes, cakes, biscotti. All are wonderful
