-
March 2024 by Jeffrey K
First time at this name pizza place. Large Veggie pizza was mostly finely chopped broccoli and no cheese on outer 2". Just specs of red pepper or olive. Also got a large meat stromboli which was overpowered with ham. I generally expect Italian sausage, pepperoni and meatball to be predominant in this dish. Won't be going back.
-
February 2024 by Anthony Patricelli
The staff is excellentThe pizza man Zac always puts out a Great pizza Always cleanParking: Can park not far from the store
-
February 2024 by Gabriel Needham
cleanest pizzeria I've been in! food is exceptional and Lou is great with the friendly customer service!
-
January 2024 by Noelia Lopez
if you want a classic pizza this is the place! The wings are amazing ! Delivery man was nice :) I’d order here again when I visit
-
January 2024 by Ray
I went with my mom to goodfellas in Publix shopping center on us1 and prima vista crossing I ordered one of those already prepared sandwiches and when he put it on my table a bug crawled out from under my food I got a full refund and will never go back there again. Beware u have been warned...
-
December 2023 by Diane Thibeault
We ordered three large pizza's at 6:00pm, pizza arrived at 7:30 & it was ice cold. When we called to complain they weren't very accomadating, they wanted us to send the pizza back.....we will never order from there again.
-
December 2023 by Tesa Warthen
I've been going to Goodfella's for 20 years and they are just as delicious as when I first visited as a child. All locations are amazing not just the original one. It's hard to find such consistency in food when there are multiple restaurants but they seem to know what they are doing.
-
December 2023 by Marlee
I ordered the 2 slices of cheese pizza and fountain drink deal and they had just reheated two slices of pizza from a pizza that had been out for a while I’m guessing. The crust was not good at all because it was reheated. The pizza is ok, there’s much better places. They also charge a fee if you use your card to pay.
-
December 2023 by Demi Stefanucci
Ordered a Bambino Special.It was undercooked and mushy.I waited out in my car and don't mind waiting until it is done. I had picked it up for friends (I don't eat pizza really) and I didn't think I had to check to see if it was well.....done.Please check your food before you leave don't make the same mistake as me ?Very nice gentleman at the register.
-
December 2023 by Justin C.
I see a lot of negative reviews on this place, but I actually ended up here by accident and I am not disappointed in that at all. Originally went to a different restaurant and ended up changing our minds and ended up here. We ordered the Sicilian pizza and was incredibly pleased with it! I will definitely be a return customer. I also saw a customer come in to pick up his pizza, they made a tiny error, and immediately corrected and got him another one going. Mistakes happen but what keeps a business moving in good customer service and they did just that
-
December 2023 by Aharon Yosef
Goodfella's makes good pizza. I especially like their 2 slices and a drink deal. The slices are huge!
-
December 2023 by Janet Paczkowski LeBlanc
Something changed at Goodfellas. We have been given burnt pies lately, Our most recent pie, the crust was so hard it was not edible from the point of a slice all the way thru. A knife had a hard time getting thru it. Threw the whole pie in the garbage. Goodfellas was our go to place for Italian food for 15 years. We will try once more. If another horrible pie, three strikes they're out!
-
November 2023 by John Werner
Tried the chicken parm roll wow awesome. Baked ziti very good. Can't wait for tiramisu for dessert.
-
October 2023 by Alyn Bryan
Always get great food and best garlic knots in town.
-
October 2023 by MaeMae Peterson
Coming from Chicago, I'm not a big fan of New York style pizza. So while I can take or leave the pizza here, the Stromboli is awesome! The Everything Stromboli is my go to at Goodfellas. I had the Fettuccine Alfredo with shrimp once or twice as well, and it was very good.