Honestly the best pizza in Sarasota!! They've had the same crew for years and they never miss!
March 2024
Everything is amazing. The pizza is fantastic and deals are even better. If you’re ever around and want a great lunch spot don’t hesitate to stop in and eat.
February 2024
Amazing pizza!Quick and tasty!!Well priced!The margarita pizza was incredible!
New York Slice Company is a New York Style Pizza joint in Sarasota, Florida. Family owned and operated, N.Y. Slice Co. offers gourmet, hand-tossed, New York style pizzas, Strombolis, and Calzones. We keep a hot slice cabinet stocked with 3 different pizza flavors for pizza-by-the-slice. Our full menu offers a wide selection of pasta dinners, salads, appetizers, and desserts. Our thin sliced roast beef is HALA certified which goes in our Philly Rolls and Italian Dip sandwich and can be used as a custom topping or filling.