Fresh Market Island is a specialty market and butcher shop offering a wide range of high-quality groceries and meats. They provide local USDA Certified Grass Fed Beef, USDA Prime cuts, and other specialty meats like Waygu, Elk, and Bison. The market also features gourmet cheeses, fresh seafood, Maryland-style crab cakes, award-winning soups and chowders, artisan breads, and a variety of specialty wines, craft beers, and ciders. Customers appreciate the fresh and locally produced grocery selection, especially the fantastic bread and unique items like GI Fungi fresh mushrooms. While the quality of the products is often praised, customer service has received mixed feedback. Some customers report feeling unwelcome and uncomfortable due to the owner's demeanor, noting that interactions can be negative and make them feel like an inconvenience. Despite this, many loyal customers express their love for the market and the value of the fresh, prepared foods, with recommendations for specific items like curry bratwurst and flank steak. The market also features a relaxing Jacaranda Garden for customer use and hosts special events. Overall, Fresh Market Island stands out for its quality offerings but faces challenges in creating a consistently welcoming atmosphere.
The best meat (steak)I found since moving to St Augustine. I am a true believer in you get what you pay for and this place doesn’t disappoint. The sourdough baguettes are fantastic and the fresh made chocolate chip cookies are worth every penny. I love shopping here
May 2026
Cool little market ... with some added options not found in other markets
April 2026
So happy to have discovered this gem. They have everything! Today's treats: European sourdough, baked purple garlic, organic curry chicken salad, Italian caviar, micro greens, South African sweets, French wine. Great 100 percent grass fed ribeye!
