Auto Insurance in Tallahassee, FL

28 locations found near Tallahassee

“Tim with Reardon State Farm was a great source of information and assistance in getting updates to our insurance accounts. He was patient and carefully explained all the options and implications. I highly recommend him and Reardon State Farm.”

5 Superb210 Reviews

“Grayson did an amazing job. Grayson explained our current coverage and what would change when we added a second vehicle. He was professional, personable, and efficient. I definitely recommend him for your insurance needs. Nate DeGraaf is lucky to have this gentleman on staff.”

5 Superb97 Reviews

“Bill Davis from Alliance Insurance Agency has provided my family with outstanding service for our insurance needs for the past 22 years. Bill's attention to clients' needs is remarkable.”

5 Superb76 Reviews

“We have been with Bridges Insurance Agency for several years. Rick and Bekah both have gone out of their way to find us the best insurance policies with the most affordable rates. If you want an insurance agency that treats you like family and looks out for your best interests then Bridges is the one for you.”

5 Superb64 Reviews

“Fantastic customer service from Kasey and Bob. They answered all of my questions and guided me entirely through the process. A lot better than my last insurance company.”

4.9 Superb161 Reviews

“Jakia Davis over at Acceptance is the best!! Please give her a call for your insurance needs. She is very thorough and aims to get the best price per policy. You will not be disappointed!!”

4.9 Superb102 Reviews

“Shanna Pohlmann provide the best customer service and had best experience with her. We can easily approach her if we need any help regarding the Home Insurance. I would recommand her for the best service.”

5 Superb43 Reviews

“I had the pleasure of speaking with Mrs Christine at the Tallahassee Geico. She is wonderful. She answered all of my questions, explained everything very clearly, and sat with me on the phone through the whole process. She even gave her contact information and told me I can call with anymore questions or if I needed help. Very sweet lady, such a pleasure to have assist me 10/10 would recommend Mrs Christine!”

4.9 Superb60 Reviews

“Scott with The Insurance Center has been my insurance agent for years! for years He has always been so helpful and knowledgeable. Scott continually makes the extra effort to make sure I am getting the best deal, and he works to be available almost any time I have a question. I am thankful to have an agent like Scott that I feel comfortable working with, and that I can trust with my insurance needs.”

5 Superb26 Reviews

“Today I came to get insurance from Acceptance and Michaela handled my policy and she was amazing. Helped me walk me through the whole thing explained everything very well. I would definitely recommend them to anybody while I was with Michaela. I mentioned that I was thirsty and the office manager Kay gave me some of her water and also offered me candy while I was here. I am so pleased with their service. I highly recommend them”

4.8 Superb87 Reviews

“Jenny Baxter.
Jenny was awesome helped me find car insurance at a great price, very helpful nice and professional! will recommend her to other! Thank you Jenny.”

4.8 Superb84 Reviews

“Jeffrey is a great insurance agent! He truly seeks to improve his clients’ insurance profile, whether it’s lower costs, improving coverage, or finding gaps in coverage, the options they offer will be tailored to your individual needs. I trust Jeffrey and his team!”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“For about two years now, Tyre Insurance Agency and Dale Tyre personally are providing me with excellent professional service at reasonable cost. I highly recommend them.”

4.8 Superb44 Reviews

“Tyler Johnson was wonderful to work with, and he helped us save a lot of money on our auto policies. Highly recommend you give him a call and let him help you save money too!”

5 Superb13 Reviews

“I’m very satisfied with the terrific experience with Mr. Waters for the last 3 years. Prompt service, competitive rates and professionalism at every step. Thank you, sir,, I highly recommend him for your insurance needs.”

4.8 Superb22 Reviews

“After 25 years of home ownership and always having homeowners insurance during those years without an incident, we had the misfortune of having 2 claims, 1 in 2019 and then 1 in 2020. Of course, our homeowners insurance then almost tripled our premium and then dropped us the next year. Our Allstate agent, Greta Langley was able to secure a new policy for us that satisfies our mortgage requirements. Greta worked hard to get the best possible homeowners insurance for us at this time and I appreciate the personal attention that she gave us during the process. We also have all 3 of our auto policies with her. I highly recommend working with Greta and her team at Allstate for all your insurance needs.”

4.8 Superb20 Reviews

“Marci Smith-Churchhill at State Farm has handled all of our auto and homeowners policies for many years. She has helped us make the best choices and always been available for calls. She is very professional and knowledgeable. I highly recommend State Farm Insurance and Marci for your insurance needs.”

4.7 Superb84 Reviews

“Always so nice working with the Affiliated Insurance Agencies team! Knowledgeable, so professional and ensured I had all of the information I needed for confidently handling my car insurance. I absolutely recommend reaching out to their team.”

4.8 Superb28 Reviews

“This is the best insurance agency I’ve ever dealt with! I have my boat, auto, as well as life insurance with them. They are very knowledgeable, always helpful, and very quick to help with anything no matter how big and small. I would recommend them to anyone looking for a great customer service experience.”

4.7 Superb50 Reviews

“It's hard to say any insurance company actually looks out for you, but this agency certainly does. Fast responses, friendly people, great coverage options and more.”

5 Superb15 Reviews

“They were very professional and friendly. I had many detailed questions, which they answered without any runaround. Good people, good prices.I highly recommend them.”

5 Superb6 Reviews

“With this State Farm office it takes just one phone call to get the job done. In my need to find just the right fit for car insurance for a friend buying a new vehicle I spoke with Akaycia at Mike Frantz State Farm office here in Tallahassee. Within a couple of hours my friend, who was getting nowhere with several other insurance companies, got straight down to business with Kayci and left the phone conversation with great relief and a policy in hand when she is ready to purchase her vehicle. Kudos for a solid commitment for professional and personal service.”

4.7 Superb44 Reviews

“Bip Bap Boop! In less than a 1/2 a hour the people at Quality Assurance cut my 6th month auto premium in half!!! I'd been with GEICO for over 20 years but they're just predators now. I wish I'd done it sooner. Worth a stop to see if they can help! I'm a real customer.”

4.7 Superb41 Reviews

“Fanny was very helpful with my auto insurance. She explained underinsured protection and highlighted the new benefits. My auto policy is easy to manage and reliable.”

4.7 Superb14 Reviews

“This is where training and a lot of the behind the scenes work is done for Capital City Bank, So I have to come here from time to time. I have worked for Capital City Bank for 10 years and I have truly enjoyed it! Not a whole lot of people enjoy their job/career, but I do!”

4.3 Superb4 Reviews

“Rebecca Babcock has been incredible to work with and a true asset to our family. She handled multiple insurance matters for both our primary home and rental property, streamlining communication and resolving issues efficiently. Most importantly, she communicated closely with my wife and took a significant amount of stress off her during a very demanding time—welcoming a new baby and adjusting to life with an expanded family.

We will be sure to stay with Mckee as long as Rebecca is employed!”

4.5 Superb51 Reviews

“Jeff Ard Jr. Researched and was able to fully and clearly articulate exactly what my insurance covered. I am extremely happy with his services. He sold me a quality insurance plan. Some brokers just sell you something. Thank you, Jeff!!!”

4.4 Superb46 Reviews

“I had an amazing experience working with Miss Gloria at Waterhouse & Associates. From the very beginning, she was incredibly warm, welcoming, and patient, which made a huge difference for me as it was my first time getting insured.

She took the time to guide me through the entire process step by step, making sure I fully understood everything and felt confident in my decisions. Her knowledge and professionalism really stood out, and she made what could have been a stressful experience feel smooth, easy, and comfortable.

I truly appreciate the care, attention, and genuine support she gave me throughout. Miss Gloria went above and beyond to make sure I had the right coverage and the knowledge I need moving forward.

Thank you so much, Miss Gloria, for everything!

— Chris W”

4.4 Superb63 Reviews