Hilltop Country Store is a beloved, nostalgic spot located in Jefferson County, conveniently between Tallahassee and Monticello. Known for its simple yet delicious food, the store offers a variety of southern staples, perfect for lunch, dinner, or a snack while traveling. Visitors frequently praise the fantastic egg salad sandwiches, homemade sides like potato salad, and a wide selection of deli sandwiches, barbecue, and wings. The chicken cheesesteak is a personal favorite among many customers, and the fried pork chop with fried okra and potato salad receives high praise for its quality. Recent visitors also enjoy the hamburger, hamburgers, fries, fried green tomatoes, teriyaki wings, and banana pudding. Everything is made to order.
The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming, with the lady at the front, owners, and employees consistently kind and polite, creating a warm environment for all guests. While the store mainly offers takeout and has outdoor seating, including picnic tables, the food quality and portion sizes are highly valued, with fair prices to match. Visitors also appreciate the store’s charm and its place as a local gem, often stopping by for chicken tenders or to try new dishes such as tuna salad, country fried steak, or the delicious Cuban. Overall, Hilltop Country Store is a great spot to enjoy tasty food, including the amazing fried green tomatoes and the best cheese curds, in a casual, friendly setting.
My new favorite go-to spot. Had an amazing lunch here, friendly staff, and a huge menu! Can't wait to come back and try something new.
October 2026
Great food, family owned and operated. Always a pleasant experience
October 2026
I went here and i was stoked to get out of the city and just have a good basic old timey deli. Just cool country folk and good food. Perfect simplicity