Payfair Supermarket is a cool, old grocery store that offers a no-frills shopping experience without the crowds. Customers appreciate its friendly staff and the convenience of finding most essentials without long lines. The store features premium steaks, Boars Head subs sliced to order, and a good selection of local craft beers, including options from Islamorada Beer Company. Many shoppers find the prices slightly higher than larger chains, but they believe the quality and convenience make it worth it. The store is particularly convenient for quick stops, especially for beer, and offers unique items like smoked Wahoo fish dip. While it closes at 7 PM, the relaxed atmosphere and great products make it a beloved local spot.
Cool old grocery store. No crowds! I was the only one there! Seems more expensive than Pubics though. Worth not dealing with a bunch of nose pickers!
April 2024
Premium steaks for the grill. It’s worth the extra money! Boars head subs with deli meat sliced to order. Steaks and subs are the best here. Closes at 7pm which is tough in summer time with sunset not til 8:30pm. Much more convenient to stop here for beer than the 7/11
April 2024
Super friendly staff!! Great local place. We stopped in to pick up beer and found a good selection from Islamorada beer company, plus some other Florida craft brews. We also picked up a smoked Wahoo fish dip that was incredible!
