September 2023 by Judy S
We've tried a lot of pizzas on the island and they are great, we use to go to Tony's but when they closed we went to all the pizza places, Coastal is our favorite by far.Food: 5/5
September 2023 by Austin Padgett
The pizza was amazing! And the customer service is also great! I also really love the rubber duckys across the restaurant. The waitress was also so kind!Food: 5/5
September 2023 by Cynthia Clark
This is pretty much the only pizza we get on the island at this point. It's the best! Also the meatballs are killer. Also pretty much every other entree or salad we've gotten is great.And you know the best part? They always check to make sure they have your order right. They also give you extra sauce when you ask for extra sauce. Everything goes smoothly at pick up.There are lots of other places on the island you can get wood fired or super thin crust pizza (or fancier ingredients), but this is the place for you if you want the most classic mid-range of thickness crust with classic toppings and good sauce.
September 2023 by Denise Benoit
I'm in here often.Best red wine.Amazing pizza.Oh, and the staff is also one of my main reasons for stopping in.Coastal Pozza is a win. Everytime.Parking: Parking at front door of establishment. Easy peasy.
September 2023 by Scott
Thought I already reviewed it. I ordered a calzone with extra ricotta, and then there was no extra ricotta because they used a cheese mixture and didn't actually have ricotta in their restaurant. If you can't make it, don't take the order and have someone pay for it. Then no real apology or refund even after contacting the owner.I was a regular who started when they were at Yulee, and haven't been back since (maybe a full year), nor will I.
August 2023 by John T
We walked in & the only tables available were in the sun and dirty. Waitress came by and wiped the table dirt off onto the seats. She just didn’t care. We walked out and won’t go back here! Take your pets here….Service: 1/5
July 2023 by Sara Baerbock
They had a gluten free crust, dairy free marinara sauce, the pepperoni was gluten free, and they accommodated no cheese so I could put my own cheese on it once it came to my table. Delicious! I loved the crispy thin crust. No problems afterwards, so it was definitely safe for me!Dietary restrictions: Gluten & dairy free friendly!
June 2023 by Jack T
Came in with Family for Dinner. Pizza was Bland and Employee's made us feel like an inconvenience. I don't recommend this place of you want friendly service. Wait times are a little long and I understand this. If you want Friendly Fast Service Even on Busy evenings go to Black Cat Pizza, You won't be Disappointed
June 2023 by Jeremy Smith
Let me start by saying there was nothing wrong with our food it’s the service and manager that made this review so low. We were a party of 8 celebrating my daughter’s graduation from high school. She was in town for the weekend and this was her last night before heading back, after most of our party left and my daughter and I were waiting to pay the bill a young lady comes by asking if she can clear the table. We of course tell her she can and she start gathering up all of the cups of drinks from the table. She ends up dropping all the cups and soaks my daughter in tea and coke, not a little it was a lot, her face, her hair her shirt was ruined and her pants all wet and sticky. The girl apologized and I know she meant it but the damage was done. I asked to speak to a manager as I felt the restaurant had really messed up even if it was unintentional it doesn’t change the fact they had caused the accident to happen. After waiting for way to long and my daughter leaving out of embarrassment finally a manger came to talk to me. First thing she said wasn’t I’m so sorry that happened, it was “accidents happen” and all we can do is comp your cannoli. I explained to her what happened as I figured she must not have realized how bad the situation was but to my surprise and anger she stuck to “accidents happen and that’s all we can do” . Seriously? On a $90 dollar bill all you can offer is the 5 dollars off the dessert??? I said forget it and left with no intention of returning, the manager must not have been thinking there are 4 or 5 other pizza places on the island and it’s a small island, do yourself a favor and go somewhere they appreciate your business because obviously they care more about profit then their customers experience!!
May 2023 by Mr. V
Guy burned our pizza and then said.... We don't know how to order a pizza. What? Be careful who you wise guy to, he may have hundreds of thousands of people looking at what they say like me? oops? or OPS! now thats good pizza! Waitress was super rude and there is nothing worse than bad service with burnt food.Food: 2/5
May 2023 by ELLEN NEWTON
Love the pizza. Staff is very pleasant. Our regular pizza place!!Vegetarian options: Love the Margarita Puzza. Fresh mozzarella!!
April 2023 by Jason Small
Coastal Pizza is our Friday night spot to go with our kids. The staff is always friendly and helpful and the pizza and apps are great. I don't know too many places these days where you can get 2 apps and a pizza for under $30.
April 2023 by Stacey Browning
I always get Tom's favorite pizza and never been a disappointment. But I sorry to say I got one yesterday and was very disappointed it's like it didn't have cheese on it. I've rather price go up then change such a great pizza.
April 2023 by Doug Menefee
Coastal Pizza is extremely customer focused and the owner comes to your table and asks how your food tasting. Their Greek salads are very delicious.Food: 5/5
February 2023 by Andrew Jabbour
If you're looking for New York style pizza this is the spot! The staff is friendly and the prices are low. The inside of the restaurant has been full every time I've been there, they have a nice bar and dozens of TVs to watch your favorite sports team. We've tried the pizza and lasagna several times and have been satisfied. Would recommend!
