-
March 2024 by Steve Tompkins
Atmosphere is N/A, order was to go.Regular crust pizza, crust was good, barely any sauce or cheese. Ordered and staff said 30 minutes, I was there, when I got back to the condo 7 minutes later pizza looked like it was cooked a hour before. Wasn't even warm. The gluten frees crust looked so much better and tasted better. One person in my party has Celiac, no wheat. Before buying and eating the gluten free option ask if there is cross contamination when preparing or in the oven, our party member was sick for 3 hours.I don't recommend the place to eat, unless you stay there to eat, so you see what they made.Steve
-
March 2024 by lizzie tullis
What an amazing place to relax and take in the atmosphere ❤️
-
March 2024 by Wenny Werner
My friends and I were there for dinner today. The food tasted pretty good. We were particularly pleasantly surprised by the service. It was the first time my friend had seen an electric cheese grater and she was amazed. Keep up the good
-
March 2024 by Donna VanStralen
As always, a delightful atmosphere, genuinely friendly, caring staff, delicious food, and out of this world desserts!!
-
February 2024 by Larry Janicek
Great food, very good service, nice staff, will go
-
February 2024 by G. Hicks
We're tourists and found this place last minute. We were surprised to learn that customers order at the counter. Okay, no problem, we waited in line and ordered our dinner. I feel badly because I feel I under-tipped, a meager ~10%, at this point assuming everything else would be self-service, getting place settings, pouring my own glasses from a bottle of wine. Also, keep in mind, that we had not had any service yet. And then, the service was top-notch, catering to our needs, pouring wine, etc. And the food (bruschetta, lasagnas, short ribs, seafood linguine) was very, very good. I regret not tipping more ~20% to your excellent staff and service. May good karma come your way with this 5-star review.
-
February 2024 by lani panda
Excited to try more pizza!
-
February 2024 by Prasanna Gorrepati
The cheese ravioli was amazing!
-
February 2024 by Nova Halavins
As a an ex-customer of Fabiani’s for almost 2 years, with an annual expenditure of around $6000, it’s with disappointment that I write this review.Our experiences have generally been positive until recent incidents raised concerns about quality control and food safety. Instances such as missing croutons in a Caesar salad or incorrect pizza preparations, or not accepting our order and making us wait for extra 40 minutes just to find out our order was not accepted were minor.However, discovering a cooked cockroach in our pizza today is alarming and unacceptable. This incident not only breaches basic food safety but also erodes the trust we had in Fabiani’s. We hope this feedback prompts a thorough inspection and improvement in quality standards to regain customer confidence.UPDATE. Alleged violation of Consumer Review Fairness Act (CRFA):Following my initial review regarding the unfortunate discovery of a foreign object in our meal, I reached out to the establishment to address the issue directly, hoping for a constructive resolution. Regrettably, the response was disheartening. Instead of addressing the concern raised or discussing potential remedies, the decision was made by the pizzeria to inform us that our patronage would no longer be welcome. This reaction, rather than focusing on resolving a genuine health and safety concern, appears to prioritize silencing and excluding customers who provide honest feedback based on their experiences.
-
February 2024 by Ray Rahne
Very friendly service. Meals were great with appropriate portions!
-
February 2024 by Jessiqa Smith
Delicious spot for Italian food!
-
November 2023 by stan hanstad
Last two times I have been to Fabiani’s food has been sub standard. All the years I have been going up until now, I have never had a problem. Something has changed of late!?
-
November 2023 by Enrique Paulo
Just a great local Italian spot. Loved the carpaccio, white pizza and the cannoli was superb. Plus they make a decent aperol spritz! We'll be back next time we're in Kihei!
-
November 2023 by R Christian Johnson
Table we sat at was literally peeling and coming apart.Music and lights were nice.Staff kept forgetting the things we asked for.Meal was not as advertised and listed on the board.Food was very expensive, but good.
-
November 2023 by William Fish
Fabiani's starts off super casual, as in, order up front at the counter and then take a table with a number on a stick. And then the food arrives. Ours was simply amazing for such a charming and simple place. One of us had the clams and linguini. Clams arrive from off island (no clams on Maui) every other day and they are super fresh and abundant. The sauce is fantastic, and did I tell you about how many fat clams were in the bowl? The other of us started with excellent beef carpaccio and then spotted the osso buco (which I did not even know they served) and it was exquisite. Lots of falling-off-the-bone meat and plenty of marrow in a great sauce. This place was such a surprise. Maui has a lot of meh places but also a bunch of real sleepers like this place (see also, Nutcharee's Thai (!), and Oao sushi in Wailea (!)). We sat outside on a cheap table and loved the atmosphere with great recorded music (no reggae for a change). Please visit this place if you enjoy classic Italian-American food.
