-
March 2024 by Stacey Cole
The food here is fantastic. The best Chicken Piccata ever. Focaccia bread is the bomb.
-
March 2024 by EdwardO
Excellent server and the rest of the staff too. Drinks are cold, salad was served fresh and chilled. The Americano pizza was fresh and served hot. Although the size of the pizza seemed a bit smaller this time it was still very delicious especially the house made sausage topping.
-
March 2024 by EdwardO
Bar server is very attentive and friendly. The rest of the staff is also attentive and friendly. Drinks are fresh and served cold. Salads are fresh and cold with large portions. The chicken cacciatore special was excellent, served hot and a large portion we split. Prices are moderate here.
-
February 2024 by TylerS
Casanova may be the best kept secret on the island. From the environment to the service. The calamari was incredible. The pasta was amazing. Casanova was easily our favorite date night while visiting the island. With everything previously stated, surprisingly, we were able to get a reservation easily the night before without needing to plan one months in advance.
-
February 2024 by Bridget Lorenz lemberg
Great pasta!
-
February 2024 by
We've been coming to Maui for 20 years and found Casanova's. We stay on the West side but always make it a point to head to Casanova's at least a couple times a visit. Food, service and value are all top notch.
-
February 2024 by
Two ordered the eggplant and it was very very cheesy. Good but too cheesy for both of them. My NY was tasty but lots of grizzle. The person who ordered the linguine with filet liked it but it definitely was not filet. The Caesar salad was terrific! The service, drinks and atmosphere was terrific as well. We would go back but order differently.
-
February 2024 by EdwardO
Excellent service by the entire staff. Drinks are cold and the fresh made focaccia bread is served hot. Tonight fish special, Ono was delicious and large portion. The special with risotto was excellent served hot and large portion also.
-
February 2024 by Aulelia K
My partner and I live in Lahaina. We drive to Makawao just to get food from Casanovas.This time, we didn’t dine in. However, it was busy there as usual and it was the superbowl.We ordered sooooo much food. The pasta with steak and mushrooms, the pasta with garlic sauce, focaccia, artichokes, kale salad, Caesar salad, tartufo pizza, and the meatball pizza.Everything was PERFECT! The pizza was delicious, the crust was crispy, the pasta was perfectly seasoned, the salads were fresh and delicious. The focaccia was tasty, and the high light was the artichokes.You will not be disappointed when dining here. They care for their take out customers as well. I would’ve loved to take photos but we dug in right away.
-
February 2024 by Denise W
In historic Makawao, comfortable ambiance and good food. Tablemate enjoyed the seafood with squid ink pasta. Many other delicious selections including pizza and vegetarian options.Parking: About 6 spaces next to restaurant. Public parking area about a block and a half walk away.
-
February 2024 by Tomatohead
My husband had the worst lobster he ever tasted with dry polenta. I enjoyed Casanova's different take on gnocchi, and our guests also appreciated the well-made pasta dishes. All-in-all a good experience.
-
February 2024 by AnthonyI
We were staying in Kaanapali beach and came here for dinner one night, it was about a 45 minute drive, but it was worth it as the food, the service, and the venue were great. While this is not located in a fancy, oceanfront, hotel or location, it was nice to see a small town on the island of Maui. Our servers name was Kai and she was spectacular. She knew the menu, made recommendations, and was just very good and very kind. I got a pizza which was good. The crust was crunchy and my daughter got pasta with the Bolognese sauce and fresh mozzarella, which she loved, the pasta was al dente exactly how she likes it so if you're looking for over done pasta that falls apart, this is not your place. my son got a pasta dish with filet mignon and mushrooms and he finished everything and my wife got pasta with clams and she said it was very good. The bread was also very good, if you like focaccia bread, it was one of the better ones we have had and we come from New York. We actually walked out without taking our credit card. We were already in the car about a half a block away, and Kai came running out to give us our credit card, she was just super nice. 
-
February 2024 by EdwardO
A Hot spot for dinner in upcountry. Fills up early right after opening at 5 pm. Cold drinks and fresh menu all served hot. Excellent staff here, very attentive and friendly. Pastas are house made fresh and served on fresh made sauces.
-
February 2024 by
Loved the experience and the service especially my server she was on it! I didn't care for waiting when I had reservations it seemed as if they were double booked. It was cold which isn't in their control but having somewhere to wait I would recommend. Food was delicious and I would eat there again.
-
February 2024 by CherylT
Absolutely fabulous Service. Our Waitress Rachel did a magnificent job all night long! Several others assisted and it was very well done! Food was tasty and served hot and in a timely manner!
