-
October 2024 by Wyatt Erickson
Our first visit to Sedlmayer's was for a fall 7 course dinner and wine pairing. We didn't know what we were in for but the reservation website pictures looked good. It was amazing! Each course was exceptional delicious. They were small enough to make it easy to eat everything. The courses were beautifully plated and every single item was intentionally designed for the fall theming. The wine selections were made by a local wine distro and every one was very intentionally good for the taste it was served with. I have never had so many different wines that uniquely integrated with the food.
I have know idea what is on Sedlmayers normal menu but if it is anything like this, wow!
Will definitely be back. I may have a new favorite for upscale date night. I should note, it wasn't cheap, but I would consider it an excellent value in premium dining.
-
September 2024 by Debra Aaron
Excellent food and great service! One of the best restaurants in the great north west you will not be disappointed!
-
September 2024 by Elizabeth
To the owners of Sedlmayer Restaurant.
The food is good.
The waitstaff is excellent.
The cooks need to pay better attention to plateing the food.
ie. Several times I have ordered food and the sides on the plate are cold, like the potatoes wether I order mashed or baked they are luke warm going cold.
Last night I ordered the New York steak medium well it came blackened no pink in the center.
We eat at your restaurant a lot and just hope the cooks can pay closer attention to how they send out the food.
-
September 2024 by Aaron
Excellent experience all the way around.
Heather was great!
-
September 2024 by Danielle Cox
We have eaten here a few times and have loved it every time. The food is wonderful and a good selection. The location is beautiful. I would definitely recommend it.
Food and drinks: I love their Steak Alfredo
-
September 2024 by Michael Coll
The very best restaurant in North Idaho. They have a small kitchen so there may be a wait but the owners and staff are top notch. Fantastic seasonal drinks and an impeccable menu with tons of options. Being that it’s the only restaurant on Spirit Lake, it has the best views in town.
-
August 2024 by Luke Jessop
Very good fries and service but a little spendy. (Just the restaurant)
-
August 2024 by Thea Raye
$17 for a dry burger with no toppings OR condiments? Are you serious? On top of that, was thrown an attitude like my presence was unnecessary.
Food and drinks: Good is expensive and subpar to put it extremely lightly.
-
August 2024 by Bill Johnson
Great food and the beautiful setting with music made for a really relaxing Sunday afternoon ?
-
August 2024 by gcleff11
Very enjoyable waterfront dinner on Spirit Lake. I really liked their take on Fish & Chips, with a light dusting of flour, so all you tasted was tender, flaky whitefish. And they give you a lot. Flat fries that accompanied the meal were pretty unique--something between a potato chip and a cottage fry. Wifey loved her Prime Rib, and did their 'special,' which is herb rubbed and quickly seared on both sides, which makes it like an end cut. Very tender, and perfectly pink inside like she prefers. Our server Abby was on it; very friendly and attentive in a bustling resto on one of the hottest days of the year. Heck, she even talked me into Boston Cream Pie, which is rather unusual because I don't have a sweet tooth. I'm sure her being a redheaded smoke show had noooothing to do with that, haha...
-
August 2024 by Melody St
The restaurant was terrible. We had a reservation for 6 and food didn’t arrive until 7:20. Waitress never came to refill water or check on our food. We were not given complementary bread, however everyone around us was served it. (The waitress was aware we were not served but she disregarded it and continued tending to other tables). About $18 for fish and chip meal and it was a small portion. Will not go again, nor recommend! My father and his wife come here often but after taking us to this place and feeling embarrassed for such HORRIBLE service, he has decided they will not come again. Good luck…
-
August 2024 by Andrea Ruiz
We camped here a few days ago and it’s a lovely place. Clean and accessible to everything. Would come back.
-
July 2024 by Bill
This was our first visit to this restaurant and the state of Idaho from Kentucky. The location sitting on the patio by the lake is gorgeous. The food, especially the fish dishes were delicious. Staff was very friendly and attentive.
-
July 2024 by Angelie Thune
The menu has so many yummy options- every thing we’ve had has been delicious. Don’t skip the dessert! Nice atmosphere and location- Spirit Lake is beautiful. Waitstaff top notch
-
July 2024 by Gordon Adams
Camping at it's best
Service and restaurant are top notch
