-
September 2023 by Rylee Morris
Whoever works daytime in the kitchen needs fired . There is no reason I should have to cut my own pizza and ontop of that trying to pull my pizza apart and nothing but cheese slides right off of it. I will not recommend this place to ANYONE for daytime pizza.
-
June 2023 by Jeanna B
Can never get the app to work to order pizza it always says the store isn’t accepting online orders. Despite calling multiple times no one has ever picked up the phone. Very frustrated after multiple times of this happening.
-
January 2023 by Clay Dwight
The gas pumps are garbage. None of them can read a chip credit/debit card. You have to go inside and guess how much fuel your vehicle needs by prepaying. Probably the most inconvenient convenience store in central Illinois
-
August 2022 by Clayton Sandidge
The gas pumps are garbage. None of them can read a chip credit/debit card. You have to go inside and guess how much fuel your vehicle needs by prepaying. Probably the most inconvenient convenience store in central Illinois
-
May 2022 by Sandy Lee
Casey's in general have great pizza's, the one in Athens where we get ours the staff is friendly and I am always greeted at the door, the area where the pizzas are made is clean and the store always well stocked. The gas prices haven't been bad either, a couple days ago when it was $4.44 in town it was still $4.29 in Athens.
-
January 2022 by Jessica H.
This store has really taken a turn for the worst with customer satisfaction. They will never get my business again. They can't keep staff and kitchen is very poorly ran. I wouldn't be surprised if more people started complaining.
-
July 2021 by Kyleigh Gum
Attempted to make an order for a pizza.. I called 6 times and nobody picked up, and the app was saying I couldn’t place the order online. Ordered a pizza and breadsticks.. didn’t get the breadsticks. Pizza was excellent! It always is.. just think more help is needed.. bad
-
July 2021 by Sarah Thomas
This is my hometown Casey's. They are clean and pretty quick to serve guests, but could use a little more "happy" people.
-
June 2021 by Todd Sexton
Worst Casey's I have ever been to. It is barely ever stocked and it's almost always dirty. If you call to order a pizza, they hardly ever answer!! If you do actually get a pizza ordered, it's under done. They don't care and it shows!
-
April 2021 by Brad Lee
Tried placing an order last night, couldn’t order online said to call the store. Tried calling the store 5 times. Not a single person answered the phone in the 30 mins I was trying to call. So I went in to get some food. Shelves are dusty, bare and barely stocked. I went in, and employees who started just last week aren’t even properly trained to run the registers by themselves & have to call people who are off, to come in a fix stuff or get help. Then they have employees who cook food in the kitchen for themselves, then walk out the store then go back in and get the food they just made, then go back to their car and eat it, then go back and get more food from the kitchen. Disgusting & unprofessional as ever in this store. Only decent employees you guys have at this location is Amanda & Kayla & Savannah. That’s it.
-
December 2020 by Steve Phillips
My favorite fresh baked pizza.
-
October 2020 by Shaun Moats
Not too wild about their product availability. The store appeared to be clean. The staff aren't very attentive to greeting their patrons. I was satisfied with being able to find a suitable refreshment but the options were not very wallet friendly.
-
October 2020 by BOBBY GLICK
Great lunch food & taco pizza ? too.
-
September 2020 by Nancee Glick
Pizza good
-
September 2020 by Kris Klemko
Great pizza
