-
March 2024 by
We had the tuna appetizer which was fantastic and everyone loved. For entrees: Our 7 year old had the kid's salmon which she thoroughly enjoyed, our 11 year old had the poké bowl which she loved (and the rest of us also enjoyed several bites of because it was a large portion!), my husband had the tuna, and I had the sea bass — both of our dishes were delicious, as was the filet medallion we added to split. We took advantage of the half price bottles of wine since it was Monday and got the Harvey and Harriet red blend. It was great that they offer to cork and bag unfinished bottles to take. We were very pleased with the quality of the food, and we were impressed with the speed in which all of the food was delivered! Our server was very conscientious about how kiddos tend to need food asap, and offered to get their entrees going while my husband and I were still deciding on ours. All around a delicious and memorable experience.
-
March 2024 by JamieTodd
Our friend recommended several restaurants, and we chose Catch 35 for it's menu choices. The restaurant had an unpretentious upscale, old-school feel, nothing super trendy. My parents would have been comfortable here. The food and service were excellent. While not inexpensive, I found it to be a solid value for the high quality. Dishes were prepared simply with high-quality ingredients. My son had the lobster roll, with fries. I had seared scallops on a bed of sauteed fresh spinach, and a tender short rib for my "surf and turf". Hardly adventurous dining, but a straightforward delicious meal. Our warm Sticky Toffee Pudding with a scoop of ice cream was the perfect sweet treat to finish. A great meal that could have been served in 1964, as well as 2024.
-
March 2024 by Wosloop
A great meal!! Classic seafood restaurant with great food, great service, and live jazz music! Had not been here in 20 years, but still a wonderful experience! I had forgotten about Catch 35, but forgotten no longer!!
-
March 2024 by Moonbeam
The service and food was outstanding. Staff was attentive to all of our needs. From the moment you enter the doors to the moment you are seated, everyone is on point. Thank you Catch 35!
-
March 2024 by Admirable1
Delicious meal! Went for a pre theater dinner. I had forgotten how lovely the ambiance was at catch 35. We had a wonderful server who was very enthusiastic. She timed our meal perfectly so we had plenty of time to walk over for the show. The shrimp in the shrimp cocktail were immense, well prepared, and delicious. I had no clue a beet salad would be this good. Our waitress said it was a favorite and I'm glad we took her recommendation. We had lobster rolls. They were stuffed and even the roll was mouthwatering! The Brussel sprout side was prepared with a Japanese twist and was not only surprising but irresistible! I'm definitely coming back!
-
March 2024 by
We went for the first time to celebrate our Dad's birthday. I called to let them know we were running a little late and only a 10-minute walk away from our hotel. Alyssa said she would make a note of that and will see us when we get there. Once we got there she greeted us and seated us at a table. The food was so delicious and everything was hot and plated nicely for presentation. We ordered what was highly recommended from the waitress: 1) Sea-bass and 2) Cedar Planked Salmon. I ordered the strawberry mojito and it was really flavorful. The waitress offered to order dessert and was very persistent. We ended up ordering the Crème Brûlée and devoured that once it arrived at the table. Once our bill arrived the waitress let us know that the dessert was paid for and we thanked her for doing that. The ambience of the restaurant was very classy and surprisingly quiet. We were sad there was no live entertainment but still enjoyed our dinner. Overall we would rate this restaurant a 10/10. Thank you for the memorable experience.
-
March 2024 by TinaP
Wonderful experience all around - from Seating to Service!!! Atmosphere was relaxed and calming. The wine (Riesling) was fantastic! Food was excellent - perfectly prepared! Our Server was very attentive and knowledgeable about the wines & menu selections.
-
March 2024 by TheRiz
We saw a play at the Nederlander Theater and picked Catch 35 because we wanted something close by, and also love seafood. Our waitress (Karen) was very attentive, offered suggestions but wasn't pushy, and helpful with our choices. Great day overall!!
-
March 2024 by
My husband and I selected this restaurant, for my birthday, based on the reviews. We are in Chicago for the weekend and were looking for a great restaurant to celebrate. These reviews cannot be true, the serving size was extremely small, my food had no seasoning (stuffed shrimp, short ribs and mashed potatoes) and is extremely overpriced for what you get. The positives were quick service, beet salad was ok, my husband's filet mignon was seasoned well and they have live music. No romantic ambience, no great food and no excitement to ever return. Truly disappointing!
-
March 2024 by
Based on the reviews, I expected a delicious meal. I'd give it a 5.5 out of 10. I was very surprised that it closed so early, and we barely got another drink before the bar closed prior to 9 on a Friday night.
-
February 2024 by Shed
Service was outstanding- everything you want in a good waiter from knowledge of the menu, attentive without being annoying and personable. The polpo was prepared perfectly - a great starter. Only disappointment is the salad dressings lack much flavor. We always finish with a slice of key lime pie that is not too sweet but has a great lime flavor
-
February 2024 by ChristopherN
Catch35 is a really nice restaurant to visit if you want to either have an intimate date or host a small group of friends. Very professional staff. The food tasted so good that I am considering coming back again soon.
-
February 2024 by ljcreeper02
The customer service at Catch 35 is top notch. Asked for either a view of outside and/or a secluded table, and was greeted with the option of which one I would prefer. The food was great. The service was great as well.
-
February 2024 by
This is top notch excellent for date night. The food is delicious, and they have valet parking. The live music was nice as well The service was top-notch. Our waiter name was Eric, totally good service.
-
February 2024 by RobK
We've been at Catch 35 for two consecutive weeks and both times had Carlos as our server. He is EXCELLENT. Really enjoyed his knowledge of the food and wine and is very personable. My wife has dietary restrictions and the chef was extremely accommodating to her needs. We definitely give the restaurant a 5-star as well as Carlos and the Chef!! Rob Kopecky 630-738-1015 (mobile)