-
March 2024 by Mark Wahmhoff
Consistently great popsicle flavors. Always worth a trip in to see what's new. Special take away pints are worth a look.
-
March 2024 by Julian-E Gonzalez Medina (PrezJay)
We really loved it! Had some phenom ice cream with very kind service. Great stop when people are visiting or even for a date!
-
March 2024 by Art Johnston
Always delicious! Servers are always super nice!
-
February 2024 by Rhonda F
I love the concept and I love shopping small business. This cute shop offers tasty ice cream in a laid back atmosphere.The guy assisting me was SO NICE!! I loved exploring all of the cool flavors and his enthusiasm was as high as mine.I bought a ton of flavors for my family. My daughter in law texted me that she cannot live without the orange creamsicle and refused to share even one bite. I loved the horchata cinnamon which was so creamy and smooth.I love everything about this place!
-
February 2024 by Lindsey Perez
Delicious treats and a fun little shop to enjoy them in.
-
January 2024 by Maxwell Leib
Love that they had hannukah themed bars!
-
December 2023 by Jane Wilberding
The best popsicles you'll ever have! There are always so many unique and fun flavors you don't see anywhere else. I have celiac and everything is GF/not cross-contaminated.Dietary restrictions: Celiac (gluten free)
-
December 2023 by Kiljoong Kim
This place is little pricey for the ice cream you get. Having said, what you also get is cool, child-friendly atmosphere. Simple but very interesting, wide variety of flavors. Perhaps not a go-to regular ice cream joint, a great alternative to any of the ice cream chains found across town.
-
October 2023 by Terry Owens
Great ice cream, a little pricey. But quality overrides the price tag
-
October 2023 by Alison
Second time here and both ice cream bars I got were sooooo good. I've tried peanut butter potato chip and coffee pretzel toffee. Such fun inventive combos, especially if you prefer salty-sweet treats. Also, the employee working was so sweet and kind in helping me pick a flavor. I feel like many in Logan Square are sleeping on this place. Highly recommend!
-
October 2023 by Helen Jun
Horchata crunch bar was the best dessert I've had all year. I thought prices looked high but after tasting this, it's an infinitely better spend than any $5 cupcake or brownie. Horchata can taste watered down but this was rich and intensely flavored and the caramel crunch dip added great texture. They also collaborated with Nick Cave and have one of his soundsuits on some wrappers so I'll keep coming back just hoping to run into him one day.
-
October 2023 by Ariana G.
I've been missing out cause this place is so good! I wish there was a location closer to me. So many fun flavors to choose from - I want to try them all!I got the caramel horchata crunch which tasted so unique to me. I can see why this place is popular with both kids and adults. I love their unique packaging as well - makes them standout from the rest. Very laid back and colorful interior with places to sit and hangout!
-
September 2023 by Steve A.
Check out the name of this place because it's pretty accurate. If looking for hand crafted ice cream bars, you will find these in here. Pretty Cool is just that. For being a place where they make their own ice cream, it's a pretty good value it seems like. There's a few non dairy flavors among the many others. A lot of good stuff to choose from. It's about $4 for an ice cream bar, which is more expensive than stuff from an ice cream truck. This is expected though because of course it's better than that and they actually make it as well. Last time got the Blue Moon. This is a coconut flavored non dairy one. Also got the Pina Colada. This one also is non dairy. This was really creamy though. Great place to cool off and eat ice cream. It has tons of flavors to get. There's some made with coconut milk that are okay for vegans.
-
September 2023 by Justin F.
Outstanding spot. Really a must try if you like ice cream and are in the neighborhood
-
September 2023 by Dustin Kozal
They don’t miss, had a dozen+ flavors and never regretted a choice, even when ordering the weirdest possible flavors (tang&ecto!).People are equally nice inside, highly recommended.
